Structural Realist Analysis of NATO–Russia Geopolitical Competition in Eastern Europe and the Origins of the Ukraine War

Структурно-реалистский анализ геополитического соперничества НАТО и России в Восточной Европе и истоков войны в Украине
Mojtaba Sotoude Kashani
2023-01-01

NATO–Russia confrontationOntological insecuritySecurity dilemmaStructural realismUkraine War
This study, drawing on a structural realist analytical approach, investigates the systemic drivers of the NATO–Russia confrontation and its ultimate outcome in the form of the Ukraine War in 2022. Through a combination of comparative historical analysis, process tracing, and discourse analysis, it reconstructs the evolution of threat construction, strategic misperceptions, and entrapment in alliance patterns from the post–Cold War period to the present. The findings indicate that the gradual expansion of NATO, the collapse of geopolitical buffer zones, and the ontological insecurity of Russian elites have intensified a mutually reinforcing security dilemma. By analyzing military doctrines, elite speeches, and strategic documents, this research demonstrates how the erosion of deterrence transparency, the resurgence of securitization, and civilizational discourse have transformed a structural conflict into a military confrontation. In this context, Ukraine, as a patterned buffer state, has become entangled in the spiral of alliance ambiguity and the logic of strategic isolation. Contrary to liberal or constructivist interpretations, this war is not viewed as the result of miscalculations or ideological divergences, but rather as the inevitable outcome of structural transformations in power polarization and the institutional consolidation of alliances. This study highlights the limitations of diplomatic crisis management without structural recalibration of the international system and offers new theoretical insights into civilizational realism and ontological insecurity during periods of multipolar transition.
1
Eroded deterrence transparency, renewed securitization, and civilizational discourse transformed a structural confrontation into direct military conflict.
2
NATO expansion, the collapse of geopolitical buffer zones, and Russian elites’ ontological insecurity mutually intensified the NATO–Russia security dilemma.
3
The study argues that diplomatic crisis management is insufficient without structural recalibration and develops insights into civilizational realism and ontological insecurity during multipolar transition.
4
The study attributes the 2022 Ukraine War primarily to structural transformations in power polarization and alliance consolidation, rather than isolated miscalculations or ideological divergence.
5
Ukraine’s role as a buffer state made it especially vulnerable to alliance ambiguity, strategic isolation, and escalating entrapment dynamics.

NATO–Russia geopolitical competition in Eastern Europe culminating in the 2022 Ukraine War

Systemic drivers and structural mechanisms of the confrontation, including alliance expansion and entrapment, buffer-zone collapse, security-dilemma intensification, deterrence erosion, and power-polarization dynamics

Publication Details
Publication Date
2023-01-01
Journal
Publisher
ISSN
Cited by
1
Access Type
Author Information
Authors
Mojtaba Sotoude Kashani
Explore further
Open the scid.ai AI chat with a ready-made request: it will find papers on a similar topic and help build a literature review.
Find similar papers in the chat
Make a presentation
100%