TRANSLATORS’ CENSORSHIP IN ENGLISH-INDONESIAN TRANSLATION OF DONALD DUCK COMICS
Цензура переводчиков при переводе комиксов о Дональде Даке с английского на индонезийский язык
2017-05-31
SCID: 54.1/nv4f9hqz
Discuss with AI
Donald Duck comicsEnglish-Indonesian translationreader-response analysistranslation techniquestranslator censorship
Figures from the paper
Abstract (AI)
Not all aspects of Western culture, reflected in the language used in Walt Disney’s Donald Duck comics, are acceptable in Indonesia. So, in translating the comics, the translators have to manipulate the text for it to be acceptable by the target readers and parents. This research aims at finding out censorship through the translation techniques used by the translators in translating the English humorous texts in the Walt Disney’s Donald Duck comics into Indonesian and the reasons underlying the translators’ choice of the translation techniques. It also aims at analysing whether or not the choice of the translation techniques affects the rendering of meaning, maintenance of humour, and acceptability of the translation. For these purposes a qualitative method was employed with content analysis technique and reader response analysis. Content analysis was used in comparing the source text (ST) and target text (TT) to find out the translation techniques used as a means of censorship and to find out the translators’ reasons for choosing the techniques. Reader-response analysis was done to find out the readers’ response to the rendering of meaning and maintenance of humour in the translation. The research findings discovered that the translators performed censorship through the dominant use of reduction and generalisation techniques so as to reduce sarcasm and insults. The interview with the publisher’s Senior Editor also revealed that “decency” was the first priority in the translation decision making, followed by clarity of meaning and maintenance of humour. Further research to investigate other elements censored, and compared with other translated comics is recommended.
Key Findings
1
Indonesian translators censored English Donald Duck comics primarily through reduction and generalisation techniques.
2
Reduction and generalisation were predominantly used to lessen sarcasm and insults for Indonesian readers and parents.
3
The authors recommend investigating additional censored elements and comparing censorship across other translated comics.
4
The publisher’s Senior Editor identified decency as the foremost translation priority, followed by clarity of meaning and humour maintenance.
5
The study combined qualitative source–target content analysis with reader-response analysis to examine censorship, meaning, humour, and acceptability.
Research Object
English-Indonesian translations of humorous texts in Walt Disney’s Donald Duck comics
Research Subject
Translator censorship through the use of reduction and generalisation, and its effects on meaning rendering, humour maintenance, and translation acceptability
Publication Details
Publication Date
2017-05-31
Journal
Publisher
ISSN
Open access PDF
Access Type
Author Information
Download PDF
Subscribe to digest