Critical appraisal of the circular economy standard BS 8001:2017 and a dashboard of quantitative system indicators for its implementation in organizations

Критическая оценка стандарта циркулярной экономики BS 8001:2017 и панель количественных системных индикаторов для его внедрения в организациях
Stefan Pauliuk
2017-10-23

BS 8001:2017circular economy indicatorslife cycle assessmentmaterial flow analysismaterial flow cost accounting
So far, organizations had no authoritative guidance on circular economy (CE) principles, strategies, implementation, and monitoring. Consequentially, the British Standards Institution recently launched a new standard “BS 8001:2017 – Framework for implementing the principles of the circular economy in organizations”. BS 8001:2017 tries to reconcile the far-reaching ambitions of the CE with established business routines. The standard contains a comprehensive list of CE terms and definitions, a set of general CE principles, a flexible management framework for implementing CE strategies in organizations, and a detailed description of economic, environmental, design, marketing, and legal issues related to the CE. The guidance on monitoring CE strategy implementation, however, remains vague. The standard stipulates that organizations are solely responsible for choosing appropriate CE indicators. Its authors do not elaborate on the links between CE strategy monitoring and the relevant and already standardized quantitative tools life cycle assessment (LCA) and material flow cost accounting (MFCA). Here a general system definition for deriving CE indicators is proposed. Based on the system definition and the indicator literature a dashboard of new and established quantitative indicators for CE strategy assessment in organizations is then compiled. The dashboard indicators are mostly based on material flow analysis (MFA), MFCA, and LCA. Steel cycle data are used to illustrate potential core CE indicators, notably, the residence time of a material in the techno-sphere (currently 250–300 years for steel). Moreover, organizations need to monitor their contribution to in-use-stock growth, a central driver of resource depletion and hindrance to closing material cycles.
1
BS 8001:2017 provides comprehensive CE terminology, principles, implementation guidance, and business-related considerations, but offers vague guidance for monitoring strategy implementation.
2
Steel-cycle data illustrate core indicators, including material residence time in the technosphere of approximately 250–300 years and organizational contributions to in-use-stock growth.
3
The dashboard primarily uses material flow analysis, material flow cost accounting, and life cycle assessment to assess CE strategies quantitatively.
4
The paper proposes a general system definition for deriving organizational CE indicators and compiles a dashboard of new and established quantitative measures.
5
The standard leaves organizations responsible for selecting CE indicators and does not clarify links between CE monitoring, life cycle assessment, and material flow cost accounting.

BS 8001:2017 circular economy implementation framework in organizations

The standard’s guidance and quantitative indicator system for assessing and monitoring circular economy strategy implementation, including material residence time and in-use-stock growth

Publication Details
Publication Date
2017-10-23
Journal
Publisher
ISSN
Cited by
627
Access Type
Author Information
Authors
Stefan Pauliuk
Explore further
Open the scid.ai AI chat with a ready-made request: it will find papers on a similar topic and help build a literature review.
Find similar papers in the chat →
Make a presentation
100%