The King Danylo Romanovich in Rus’-Mongolian Relations: Discussion Questions of Historiography

Король Данило Романович в русско-монгольских отношениях: дискуссионные вопросы историографии
Тарас Чугуй
2019-01-01

Danylo RomanovichGalician-Volyn stateGolden HordeMongol military tacticsRus’-Mongolian relations
The article analyzes topical issues of the Rus’-Mongolian relations of the times of King of Rus’ Danylo Romanovich. The consideration of the discussion aspects of political relations between Rus’ and the Golden Horde in the historiography is analyzed. It is concluded that the impression made by the Mongols on young Prince Danylo during the Battle on the Kalka River prompted him to engage in reforming his own army borrowing from Mongolian tactics and weapons. The establishment of the power of the Galician-Volyn ruler in Kyiv in 1239 caused the Mongol conquerors to seize not only the ancient capital of Rus’, but also the towns Volodymyr and Galich. Danylo Romanovich’s attempts to organize a joint struggle with the Hungarians and Poles against mongols in the 1240s and 1241s failed. Despite the fact that the campaigns of the Mongol troops caused great losses, we consider the hypothesis of the complete desolation of the Rus’ Land to be obsolete and unsubstantiated. At the same time Bolokhivshchyna and Pereyaslavshchyna were under the direct authority of Mongolian officials. Instead, the dependence of the Galich and Volyn lands on the Mongols was nominal because the Romanoviches continued to pursue independent domestic and foreign policies. Danylo’s status as a “mirnik” of Khan Batu facilitated a political alliance with the Hungarian King Bela IV. The political agreement of Danylo Romanovich with Andriy Yaroslavovich caused a sharp negative reaction in the Mongols. After the victory of Nevruy over the Prince of Vladimir-Suzdal in 1252 against Danylo Kuremsa began military action. However, due to the decisive actions of Romanoviches Kuremsa was repeatedly defeated. The confirmation of Danylo Romanovich’s sovereign status was his coronation in the second half of 1253. The last stage of the relations of King of Rus’ Danylo Romanovich with the Mongols took place in the late 50’s – early 60’s of the XIII century. Burundai was able not only to destroy Danyl’s alliance with Lithuania, but also to restore Khan’s dominion over Romanovich’s possessions. It is important to emphasize that Romanovichi remained in the status of “mirnik” not “dannik” as rulers of Northeast Rus’. The absence of the Basques, as well as the transfer by the Mongols of the shortcut to Kyiv to the Vladimir-Suzdal Princes directly dependent on the Golden Horde once again underlines another legal status of the Galician and Volyn Lands.
1
Bolokhivshchyna and Pereyaslavshchyna fell under direct Mongol administration, whereas Galich and Volyn retained nominal dependence and pursued independent domestic and foreign policies.
2
Danylo Romanovich’s exposure to Mongolian tactics at the Battle of the Kalka River prompted reforms of his army’s tactics and weaponry.
3
Danylo’s alliances with Béla IV of Hungary and Andriy Yaroslavovich provoked Mongol opposition; despite Kuremsa’s campaigns, the Romanoviches repeatedly defeated his forces, and Danylo’s sovereignty was symbolized by his coronation in 1253.
4
Danylo’s attempts to coordinate anti-Mongol resistance with Hungary and Poland in the 1240s–1241s failed, while the hypothesis of complete Rus’ devastation is considered obsolete and unsubstantiated.
5
The Galician-Volyn ruler’s control of Kyiv in 1239 contributed to Mongol seizures of Kyiv, Volodymyr, and Galich.

Rus’-Mongolian political relations during the reign of King Danylo Romanovich

Historiographical debates concerning the forms, extent, and dynamics of Mongol dependence and political interaction between the Galician-Volhynian state and the Mongols

Publication Details
Publication Date
2019-01-01
Journal
Publisher
ISSN
Access Type
Author Information
Authors
Тарас Чугуй
Explore further
Open the scid.ai AI chat with a ready-made request: it will find papers on a similar topic and help build a literature review.
Find similar papers in the chat
Make a presentation
100%