The Medieval Roots of Democracy

Средневековые корни демократии
Jørgen Møller
2015-07-01

democratizationmilitary revolutionpolitical accountabilitysequencing debatestate-building
A point of consensus in the so-called “sequencing debate” is that in Europe state-building preceded the development of political accountability, eventually in the form of democratization, by centuries. This is arguably a misrepresentation of the European sequence. Strong institutions of constraints were an integrated part of the political regime form when large-scale state-building began following the sixteenth-century military revolution. European state-builders were therefore checked by countervailing political power but were also able to channel authority through existing institutions. A comparison with Russia shows that it was on this basis that both the modern state and modern democracy emerged and took root in the nineteenth and early twentieth centuries.
1
Comparison with Russia suggests that these institutional foundations enabled both the modern state and modern democracy to emerge and become established in the nineteenth and early twentieth centuries.
2
European state-builders faced countervailing political power while channeling authority through pre-existing institutions.
3
Institutions constraining rulers were already integrated into European political regimes when large-scale state-building accelerated after the sixteenth-century military revolution.
4
The abstract challenges the sequencing debate’s claim that European state-building preceded political accountability by centuries.

European state-building and political regimes, compared with Russia, from the sixteenth to the early twentieth century

The historical relationship between institutions of constraint, countervailing political power, state formation, and the emergence of modern democracy

Publication Details
Publication Date
2015-07-01
Journal
Publisher
ISSN
Access Type
Author Information
Authors
Jørgen Møller
Explore further
Open the scid.ai AI chat with a ready-made request: it will find papers on a similar topic and help build a literature review.
Find similar papers in the chat
Make a presentation
100%