Review: Towards an integrated concept of animal welfare

Обзор: К интегрированной концепции благополучия животных
Laura E. Webb, Inonge Reimert, Manon A. van Marwijk, Jantina Elizabeth Bolhuis
2023-08-01

affective statesanimal sentienceanimal welfarepleasant and unpleasant experienceswelfare assessment levels
Animal welfare is an important field of study due to animal sentience, yet there is to date no consensus on the definition of animal welfare. There have been four key developments in the field of animal welfare science since its birth: the theoretical and empirical study of affective states, and hence our understanding thereof, has increased; there has been a shift from a primary focus on unpleasant experiences towards an inclusion of pleasant experiences; there has been an increasing mention and investigation of the notion of cumulation of experiences in time, and with this, the importance of the time component of both affective states and animal welfare has come forward. Following others, we define welfare as a balance or cumulation of pleasant and unpleasant experiences over time. The time period of welfare depends on when welfare considerations are necessary, and may range from the duration of single and relatively short-term experiences to the entire life of an animal. We further propose that animal welfare conceptualised in this way can be assessed at three levels: level 1 represents the assessment of the environment and 'internal factors' such as health and personality, which interact in their impact on the affective experiences of animals; level 2 represents the assessment of affective states; and level 3 represents the assessment of the balance or cumulation of these affective states in time. The advancement of research necessitates studies to be more or less comparable, and this would be facilitated by researchers mentioning which concept of animal welfare they are basing their work on, at which level of assessment they are working, which assumptions they might be drawing from to infer welfare and which time period of interest they are focusing on, even if this is not mirrored by the timing of the assessment in practice. Assessment at levels 2 and 3 still needs much study, at both the theoretical and empirical levels, including agreements on validation tools.
1
Animal welfare can be assessed at three levels: environmental and internal factors, affective states, and their balance or cumulative effects over time.
2
Animal welfare lacks a consensus definition, despite increasing recognition of animal sentience and advances in welfare science.
3
Progress requires researchers to specify their welfare concept, assessment level, inferential assumptions, and time period; levels 2 and 3 still require substantial theoretical and empirical validation.
4
Recent developments emphasize affective states, inclusion of pleasant as well as unpleasant experiences, and cumulative effects over time.
5
The paper defines welfare as the balance or cumulation of pleasant and unpleasant experiences over a specified time period, potentially ranging from brief experiences to an animal’s entire life.

animal welfare

the integrated conceptualization and assessment of animal welfare as the balance or cumulation of pleasant and unpleasant affective experiences over time, including environmental, internal, affective-state, and temporal components

Publication Details
Publication Date
2023-08-01
Journal
Publisher
ISSN
Cited by
120
Access Type
Author Information
Authors
Laura E. Webb
Inonge Reimert
Manon A. van Marwijk
Jantina Elizabeth Bolhuis
Explore further
Open the scid.ai AI chat with a ready-made request: it will find papers on a similar topic and help build a literature review.
Find similar papers in the chat →
Make a presentation
100%