Old-Believer Martyrs and Religious Discipline at the Turn of the 17th–18th Centuries

Старообрядческие мученики и религиозная дисциплина на рубеже XVII–XVIII веков
Alexey Popovich
2024-01-01

Old BelieversPetrine eraanti-Old Believer literaturemartyr discoursereligious discipline
The study is devoted to strategies for polemics with the martyr discourse constructed by the Old Believers in relation to themselves and their own saints in the late 17th — early 18th centuries. Anti_Old Believer literature denounced the glorification of martyrs who suffered because of persecution or self-immolation as superstitions. It was part of the religious discipline. The article demonstrates that the veneration of “false” martyrs was characterized as hypocrisy long before the spiritual reform of Peter I. Opponents of the schism at the beginning of the 18th century (Feofan Prokopovich, Feofilakt Lopatinsky, Dimitry Rostovsky, I. T. Pososhkov) used the same ideas and techniques as the writers of the patriarchal circle (Afanasy Kholmogorsky, Ignaty Rimsky-Korsakov, etc.) and other authors of the 17th century (Simeon Polotsky, the creators of the Acts of the Moscow Councils, Juraj Križanić and the author of “Brozda Dukhovnaya”). They were all united in their opposition to the Old Believer ideas about holiness and soteriology. The disengagement of official polemicists became apparent in the Petrine era, when the ideas of rationalizing Christian piety and the monopoly of state power on martyrs became widespread, while other points of view on the path to the salvation of the soul were on the periphery.
1
Anti-Old Believer literature portrayed the veneration of martyrs persecuted or self-immolated as superstition and hypocrisy, making this condemnation part of religious discipline.
2
During the Petrine era, official polemics increasingly promoted rationalized Christian piety and the state’s monopoly over martyr recognition, marginalizing alternative paths to salvation.
3
Early eighteenth-century opponents of the schism reused polemical ideas and techniques developed by seventeenth-century and patriarchal-circle writers.
4
The characterization of “false” martyr veneration as hypocrisy appeared before Peter I’s spiritual reforms, rather than originating exclusively in the Petrine era.
5
These polemicists shared opposition to Old Believer concepts of holiness and salvation, despite differences among their institutional and historical contexts.

Old Believer martyr discourse and its treatment in late 17th–early 18th-century anti-Old Believer religious polemics

Polemical strategies for delegitimizing Old Believer martyr veneration and reshaping ideas of holiness, religious discipline, and salvation

Publication Details
Publication Date
2024-01-01
Journal
Publisher
ISSN
Cited by
0
Access Type
Author Information
Authors
Alexey Popovich
Explore further
Open the scid.ai AI chat with a ready-made request: it will find papers on a similar topic and help build a literature review.
Find similar papers in the chat
Make a presentation
100%