The Concept of <i>Commorientes</i> in French and Russian Inheritance Law
Понятие commorientes во французском и российском наследственном праве
2020-03-27
SCID: 54.1/quw66rme
Discuss with AI
French Civil CodeRussian Federation Civil Codecommorientessimultaneous death presumptiontime of inheritance opening
Figures from the paper
Abstract (AI)
The article is devoted to the consideration of the concept of commorientes in French and Russian inheritance law. The commorientes are individuals, entitled to inherit, reciprocally, to each other and considered to have died at the same moment, from the inheritance’s point of view. The commorientes do not inherit reciprocally. The work focuses on how French and Russian law determine the notion of commorientes. Inheritance rules, regarding the commorientes in France and Russian Federation from the beginning of the 19th century are analysed; subsequently, their current versions in force in the French Civil Code and the Russian Federation Civil Code are compared. Particular attention is paid to the issue of the time of the inheritance opening. In the Russian legislation this issue has not been unambiguously resolved for a long time. The article presents the evolution of the Russian and French rules on inheritance after the commorientes. In French law, presumptions of survival have been in effect for many years, allowing to determine the sequence of deaths of people who died as a result of the same event. The article contains the rules of the current legislation in France and in the Russian Federation, as well as suggestions for their improvement.
Key Findings
1
Commorientes are persons entitled to inherit from each other who are treated as having died simultaneously for inheritance purposes, and therefore do not inherit reciprocally.
2
French law has long used presumptions of survival to determine the sequence of deaths for persons who died in the same event.
3
Russian legislation on the moment of inheritance opening in commorientes cases has been ambiguous for a long time and evolved over time.
4
The article analyzes how French and Russian law define and determine commorientes, tracing rules from the early 19th century to current codes.
5
The paper compares current French Civil Code and Russian Federation Civil Code rules on commorientes and offers suggestions for legislative improvement.
Research Object
The legal concept of commorientes in French and Russian inheritance law
Research Subject
How French and Russian law define and regulate commorientes, including historical evolution, comparative analysis of current Civil Code provisions, presumptions of survival, and the issue of time of inheritance opening
Publication Details
Publication Date
2020-03-27
Journal
Publisher
ISSN
Open access PDF
Access Type
Author Information
Download PDF
Subscribe to digest