Attrition and the Management of Pediatric Obesity: An Integrative Review

Отсев и ведение детского ожирения: интегративный обзор
Jasmine Dhaliwal, Nicole Nosworthy, Nicholas L. Holt, Lonnie Zwaigenbaum, Jillian L.S. Avis, Allison M. Rasquinha, Geoff D.C. Ball
2014-12-01

family-based interventionslifestyle and behavioral changeslogistical barrierspediatric obesity managementprogram attrition
BACKGROUND: A key challenge in managing pediatric obesity is the high degree of program attrition, which can reduce therapeutic benefits and contribute to inefficient health services delivery. Our aim was to document and characterize predictors of, and reasons for, attrition in pediatric obesity management. METHODS: We searched literature published until January 2014 in five databases (CINAHL, EMBASE, MEDLINE, PsycINFO, and Scopus). Articles were included if they were English, included participants 0-18 years of age, focused on pediatric obesity management, incorporated lifestyle and behavioral changes without pharmacotherapy, provided attrition data, and reported information about predictors of, and/or reasons for, attrition from family-based interventions provided in research or clinical settings. Twenty-three articles (n=20 quantitative; n=2 qualitative; n=1 mixed methods) met our inclusion criteria. Clarity of study aims, objectives, methods, and data analysis were appraised using Bowling's checklist. RESULTS: Attrition varied according to definition (minimum to maximum, 4-83%; median, 37%). There were few consistent predictors of attrition between studies, although dropout was higher among US-based families receiving public health insurance. Older children were also more likely to discontinue care, but sex and baseline weight status did not predict attrition. The most commonly reported reasons for attrition were logistical barriers and programs not meeting families' needs. CONCLUSIONS: Developing and evaluating strategies designed to minimize the risk of attrition, especially among families who receive public health insurance and older boys and girls, are needed to optimize the effectiveness of pediatric obesity management.
1
Few predictors were consistent across studies; attrition was higher among US families receiving public health insurance and among older children.
2
Reported attrition ranged widely from 4% to 83%, with a median of 37%, depending on the definition used.
3
Sex and baseline weight status did not predict attrition in pediatric obesity management programs.
4
Strategies to reduce attrition should particularly target publicly insured families and older children to improve program effectiveness.
5
The integrative review included 23 studies examining attrition predictors and reasons in family-based pediatric obesity management.
6
The most commonly reported reasons for dropout were logistical barriers and programs failing to meet families’ needs.

Family-based pediatric obesity management interventions for children and adolescents aged 0–18 years

Program attrition, including its predictors and reported reasons, in pediatric obesity management

Publication Details
Publication Date
2014-12-01
Journal
Childhood Obesity
Publisher
Mary Ann Liebert, Inc.
ISSN
2153-2168
Cited by
187
Access Type
Author Information
Authors
Jasmine Dhaliwal
Nicole Nosworthy
Nicholas L. Holt
Lonnie Zwaigenbaum
Jillian L.S. Avis
Allison M. Rasquinha
Geoff D.C. Ball
Explore further
Open the scid.ai AI chat with a ready-made request: it will find papers on a similar topic and help build a literature review.
Find similar papers in the chat →
Make a presentation
100%