Detection of Milk Fat Adulteration in Commercial Butter and Sour Cream

Обнаружение фальсификации молочного жира в коммерческом масле и сметане
Bernard Faye, Moldir Nurseitova, G.S. Konuspayev, A.A. Zhakupbeko, Farida Amutova, Anara Omarova, Askar Kondybayev, G.A. Bayandy, N.N. Akhmetsady
2021-01-15

Kruskal-Wallis testPearson correlationbutterfatty acid composition (GC-FID)milk fat adulterationphytosterolsprincipal component analysis (PCA)sour creamsterol profile (GC-MS)β-sitosterol
Background and Objective: Adulteration of dairy products by substitution of milk fat by vegetable oil is common in the Eurasian Economic Union. The objective of the paper is to investigate the potential adulteration of the fat and to test the more convenient methods of detection, i.e., determination of fatty acids or sterols profiles in commercial butter and cream. Materials and Methods: Ten samples of commercial butter and 8 samples of commercial sour cream were collected on the national market of Kazakhstan. The analyses involved the original sour cream and butter without any modification (deep-freezing) and were achieved within the shelf-life period. The fatty acid composition was analyzed by GS-FID and Sterol fractions were analyzed by GS-MS. Statistical analysis was achieved by principal components analysis (PCA), Pearson types, Kruskal-Wallis test. Results: Sixty percent of the butter samples contained traces of phytosterols and one sample contained up to 78% $-sitosterol. In sour cream samples, only three contained 100% cholesterol while two contained more than 60% sitosterol. The detection of fat adulteration by analyzing the fatty acids patterns is convenient in case of massive substitution of milk fat, but a discrete substitution does not modify the fatty acids profiles leading to misinterpretation. Conclusion: The results exhort to give preference to sterol profile determination as an official method to detect fat adulteration in dairy products. This is even more important as the current standard used in Central Asia based on some fatty acids ratios can lead to incorrect conclusions.
1
60% of commercial butter samples contained traces of phytosterols, indicating vegetable oil adulteration.
2
Fatty acid pattern analysis reliably detects massive substitution of milk fat but fails to detect discrete (partial) substitutions.
3
In sour cream samples, only three contained 100% cholesterol while two contained more than 60% sitosterol, indicating adulteration in some samples.
4
One butter sample contained up to 78% β-sitosterol, showing extensive non-dairy fat presence.
5
Sterol profile determination is recommended as the preferred official method to detect fat adulteration, since fatty acid ratio–based standards can give incorrect conclusions.

Commercial butter and sour cream samples from the Kazakhstan market

Detection of milk fat adulteration by vegetable oil through analysis of fatty acid and sterol profiles, and evaluation of sterol profiling versus fatty-acid-based methods for accuracy in identifying substitution

Publication Details
Publication Date
2021-01-15
Journal
Publisher
ISSN
Cited by
10
Access Type
Author Information
Authors
Bernard Faye
Moldir Nurseitova
G.S. Konuspayev
A.A. Zhakupbeko
Farida Amutova
Anara Omarova
Askar Kondybayev
G.A. Bayandy
N.N. Akhmetsady
Explore further
Open the scid.ai AI chat with a ready-made request: it will find papers on a similar topic and help build a literature review.
Find similar papers in the chat
Make a presentation
100%