Tightening Environmental Standards: The Benefit-Cost or the No-Cost Paradigm?

Ужесточение экологических стандартов: парадигма «затраты—выгоды» или парадигма отсутствия затрат?
Paul R. Portney, Karen Palmer, Wallace E. Oates
1995-11-01

Porter hypothesisbenefit-cost analysiscontrol costsenvironmental qualityenvironmental regulation
This paper takes issue with the Porter-van der Linde claim that traditional benefit-cost analysis is a fundamental misrepresentation of the environmental problem. They contend that stringent environmental measures induce innovative efforts leading to improvements in abatement and production technologies that offset the costs of the regulations. Drawing both on basic economic theory and existing data on control costs, the authors argue that such offsets are special cases. The data indicate offsets are minuscule relative to control costs. There is no free lunch here: environmental programs must justify their costs by the benefits that improved environmental quality provides to society.
1
Economic theory and existing control-cost data indicate that cost offsets from regulatory-induced innovation are special cases rather than the norm.
2
Environmental programs should be justified by the societal benefits of improved environmental quality relative to their costs.
3
Observed offsets are minuscule relative to environmental control costs, providing no evidence for a general no-cost paradigm.
4
The paper challenges the Porter–van der Linde claim that stringent environmental regulation generally offsets its own compliance costs through innovation.

Stringent environmental regulations (tightened environmental standards)

whether innovation-induced cost offsets from stringent environmental regulations are significant relative to control costs and can replace benefit-cost justification

Publication Details
Publication Date
1995-11-01
Journal
Publisher
ISSN
Cited by
1749
Access Type
Author Information
Authors
Paul R. Portney
Karen Palmer
Wallace E. Oates
Explore further
Open the scid.ai AI chat with a ready-made request: it will find papers on a similar topic and help build a literature review.
Find similar papers in the chat →
Make a presentation
100%