Searching for a New Identity in a New Era: Emergence and Development of Sakha (Yakutia) as an Arctic Region
Поиск новой идентичности в новую эпоху: возникновение и развитие Саха (Якутии) как арктического региона
2020-01-01
SCID: 54.1/rmrqpzkk
Discuss with AI
Arctic regionSakha identitySoviet modernizationcolonialism in Central Asianational identities
Figures from the paper
Abstract (AI)
The article addresses the infl uence on Central Asian reality exerted by naming and the practice of identifying the peoples inhabiting this area by dominant Others.I note that the identifi cation of those human communities was always an act of aggression that led to establishing a relation between rulers and those subordinate to them.I submit that what joins various epochs in the history of the human communities of Central Asia is not imperialism but rather colonialism, and propose describing those processes by means of a systemic concept of colonialism.Imperial practice in Central Asia was based on subordinating tribal communities and non-national states without deeper interference into their inner structures.Up until the 20th century the three great powers jockeyed above all to block one another.The change following the collapse of the USSR did not lead to the creation of regional independence.Rather, the national identities of the new states are a product of the modernization compelled by Soviet policies.This especially concerns small communities that, always valuing their autonomy, did not strike observers-explorers as material for nations.The preponderance of the external point of view along with the infl uence of images arisen in the dominant surrounding (including that of science) maintain these * This paper is an extensively modifi ed version of a lecture of the same title, delivered during the workshop "Facing the Challenge of Identifi cation: New Approaches to Buryat Identities and Their Cross-Border Dynamics" in Warsaw in June 2016.Tajikistan (Gorno-Badakhshan)."In Mapping Transition in the Pamirs: With Case Studies on the Changing Human-Environmental Landscapes, edited by H. Kreutzmann and T.
Key Findings
1
External perspectives and dominant scientific images continue shaping the identities of small communities that historically valued autonomy and were not viewed as nation-forming groups.
2
Imperial rule generally subordinated tribal communities and non-national states while avoiding deep intervention in their internal structures.
3
It proposes colonialism, rather than imperialism alone, as the systemic concept linking different historical periods in Central Asia.
4
The abstract argues that naming and identifying Central Asian peoples by dominant outsiders constituted an act of aggression establishing ruler–subordinate relations.
5
The collapse of the USSR did not produce genuine regional independence; new national identities emerged through modernization imposed by Soviet policies.
Research Object
Sakha (Yakutia) as an Arctic region and its inhabitants’ identity formation
Research Subject
The emergence and development of regional and national identity under external naming, colonial relations, and Soviet modernization
Publication Details
Publication Date
2020-01-01
Journal
Publisher
ISSN
Open access PDF
Access Type
Author Information
Download PDF
Subscribe to digest