Shifting paradigms: People-centred models, active regional development, space-blind policies and place-based approaches

Смена парадигм: модели, ориентированные на людей, активное региональное развитие, пространственно нейтральная политика и подходы, основанные на специфике территорий
Gill Bentley, Lee Pugalis
2014-06-01

active regional developmentpeople-centred modelsplace-based approachesspace-blind policiesterritorial inequalities
There is gathering academic and policy momentum, although not without challenge, critique and ferocious debate, that an apparent ‘place-based’ mode of activity has emerged. Such a paradigm shift may in part be explained as a response to the deficiencies of ‘people-centred’ models, active regional development and space-blind policies. This article critically reviews some of the primary literatures relating to these competing, contradictory and also complementary methods of development. The place-based mode of working can be conceptualised as potentially offering the scope, through supportive institutional frameworks and collaborative means of governance, for developing embedded, multi-scalar and multi-annual strategies that are tailored to the complex geographies, capabilities, knowledge-sets, assets and resources of particular places (and networks of places). Whilst appearing to offer a panacea for securing economic growth in a sustainable and socially inclusive manner that releases the potential, creativity and knowledge of local actants, the dominant narrative associated with the place-based approach has not escaped critique and controversy. It is our contention that place-based thinking reflects the continual search for solutions to address territorial, social and economic inequalities and development capacities. Whether it provides a workable policy solution will be contingent on a number of factors, not least spatial context in terms of social, cultural, economic and institutional characteristics. Reflecting the multiplicity of places, place-based approaches, in raising questions about the relationship between scales of operation and institutional structures, are a subset of broader debates and issues concerning not only what works but also where.
1
A place-based development paradigm has emerged partly in response to perceived deficiencies of people-centred models, active regional development, and space-blind policies.
2
Although place-based approaches promise sustainable and socially inclusive growth, they remain subject to substantial critique and controversy rather than constituting a universal solution.
3
Place-based approaches can support embedded, multi-scalar, and multi-annual strategies tailored to the capabilities, knowledge, assets, and resources of particular places and interlinked regions.
4
Place-based thinking contributes to broader debates about territorial inequality, development capacity, institutional structures, and the relationship between operational scales and policy effectiveness.
5
Supportive institutions and collaborative governance are necessary conditions for implementing effective place-based development strategies.
6
The effectiveness of place-based policy depends on spatial context, including the social, cultural, economic, and institutional characteristics of places.

place-based development approaches and their relationship to people-centred models, active regional development, and space-blind policies

the conceptual foundations, comparative strengths and limitations, and contextual conditions of competing development approaches for addressing territorial, social, and economic inequalities

Publication Details
Publication Date
2014-06-01
Journal
Publisher
ISSN
Cited by
97
Access Type
Author Information
Authors
Gill Bentley
Lee Pugalis
Explore further
Open the scid.ai AI chat with a ready-made request: it will find papers on a similar topic and help build a literature review.
Find similar papers in the chat →
Make a presentation
100%