Digital maturity and digital transformation maturity models: a systematic literature review

Модели цифровой зрелости и зрелости цифровой трансформации: систематический обзор литературы
Anda Larisa ȘTEF, Emil Lucian Crișan, Daniela Vararean-Cochisa
2026-07-16

CIMO frameworkdigital maturity modelsdigital transformationdigital transformation maturity modelssystematic literature review
Abstract Digital transformation (DT) is a major challenge for organisations. Digital maturity models (DMMs) and digital transformation maturity models (DTMMs) have been developed to help decision-makers in making decisions about DT. The terms DMM and DTMM are used interchangeably and have evolved in parallel, and this duality has generated confusion for both researchers and practitioners. The goal of this paper is to generate more prescriptive knowledge for understanding these maturity models related to digital phenomena. For this purpose, we review 60 papers that discuss DMMs and DTMMs using the context-intervention-mechanism-outcome (CIMO) theoretical framework of analysis. The results reveal four fundamental mechanisms that explain how maturity models in this field of study are constructed and used: models focused on the outcomes of digital transformation (DMMs), models centred on the process of digital transformation (DTMMs), mixed models (focusing on both outcomes and processes associated with DT), and strategic models, which evaluate the outcomes, process, and strategy of DT. Considering the differences between DMMs and DTMMs, the paper identifies theoretical and methodological gaps in current research while providing valuable results for researchers in developing new models, and for practitioners in selecting the most appropriate maturity model for their organisations in their DT path.
1
A systematic review of 60 papers applies the context-intervention-mechanism-outcome framework to digital maturity and digital transformation maturity models.
2
DMMs and DTMMs are often used interchangeably despite conceptual differences, creating confusion for researchers and practitioners.
3
Four construction and usage mechanisms are identified: outcome-focused DMMs, process-focused DTMMs, mixed models, and strategic models covering outcomes, processes, and strategy.
4
The findings provide guidance for developing new models and selecting appropriate models for organisations pursuing digital transformation.
5
The review identifies theoretical and methodological gaps in current maturity-model research.

Digital maturity models (DMMs) and digital transformation maturity models (DTMMs)

The construction, use, and conceptual differences of DMMs and DTMMs, including their focus on digital transformation outcomes, processes, and strategy

Publication Details
Publication Date
2026-07-16
Journal
Publisher
ISSN
Cited by
1
Access Type
Author Information
Authors
Anda Larisa ȘTEF
Emil Lucian Crișan
Daniela Vararean-Cochisa
Explore further
Open the scid.ai AI chat with a ready-made request: it will find papers on a similar topic and help build a literature review.
Find similar papers in the chat →
Make a presentation
100%