Is artificial intelligence improving the audit process?
Улучшает ли искусственный интеллект процесс аудита?
2022-07-07
SCID: 54.1/s4xyqv93
Discuss with AI
artificial intelligenceaudit efficiencyaudit qualityaudit restatementsaudit workforce
Figures from the paper
Abstract (AI)
Abstract How does artificial intelligence (AI) impact audit quality and efficiency? We explore this question by leveraging a unique dataset of more than 310,000 detailed individual resumes for the 36 largest audit firms to identify audit firms’ employment of AI workers. We provide a first look into the AI workforce within the auditing sector. AI workers tend to be male and relatively young and hold mostly but not exclusively technical degrees. Importantly, AI is a centralized function within the firm, with workers concentrating in a handful of teams and geographic locations. Our results show that investing in AI helps improve audit quality, reduces fees, and ultimately displaces human auditors, although the effect on labor takes several years to materialize. Specifically, a one-standard-deviation change in recent AI investments is associated with a 5.0% reduction in the likelihood of an audit restatement, a 0.9% drop in audit fees, and a reduction in the number of accounting employees that reaches 3.6% after three years and 7.1% after four years. Our empirical analyses are supported by in-depth interviews with 17 audit partners representing the eight largest U.S. public accounting firms, which show that (1) AI is developed centrally; (2) AI is widely used in audit; and (3) the primary goal for using AI in audit is improved quality, followed by efficiency.
Key Findings
1
A one-standard-deviation increase in recent AI investment is associated with a 5.0% lower likelihood of audit restatement and a 0.9% reduction in audit fees.
2
AI investment is associated with delayed displacement of accounting employees, reaching 3.6% after three years and 7.1% after four years.
3
Audit-firm AI workers are predominantly male, relatively young, technically educated, and concentrated in a small number of centralized teams and locations.
4
Interviews with 17 partners indicate that AI is centrally developed, widely used in auditing, and primarily intended to improve quality, followed by efficiency.
5
Using resumes from over 310,000 employees across 36 major audit firms, the study identifies and characterizes the auditing sector’s AI workforce.
Research Object
AI workforce and AI investments within large audit firms and the auditing sector
Research Subject
The effects of AI adoption and investment on audit quality, audit fees, efficiency, and employment of human auditors
Publication Details
Publication Date
2022-07-07
Journal
Publisher
ISSN
Cited by
460
Open access PDF
Access Type
Author Information
Download PDF
Subscribe to digest