Market Competition and Corporate ESG Greenwashing: A Perspective From New Entrants

Рыночная конкуренция и корпоративный ESG-гринвошинг: взгляд с позиции новых участников рынка
Yaya Su, Conghao Zhu, Khaldoon Albitar
2025-10-25

ESG greenwashingmanagerial confidencemarket competitionnew firm entrytwo-way fixed effects
ABSTRACT Against the backdrop of the rapid proliferation of environmental, social, and governance (ESG) principles, the phenomenon of corporate greenwashing has garnered increasing attention. Drawing upon data from A‐share listed companies in China between 2009 and 2022, this study investigates how competitive pressure influences corporate greenwashing in the ESG domain. Market competition is measured by the number of newly registered firms at the city‐industry level, while a greenwashing index is constructed based on the deviation between ESG disclosure scores and actual performance ratings. Employing a range of empirical methods, including two‐way fixed effects models and instrumental variable approaches, the analysis reveals that the entry of new firms significantly intensifies greenwashing behavior among incumbent enterprises. This effect primarily operates through the erosion of managerial confidence and the amplification of short‐termism. However, executives with strong environmental awareness or sustainability‐related backgrounds, as well as robust ESG disclosure mechanisms, can partially mitigate this tendency. External forces such as institutional investors' on‐site investigations, media oversight, and government regulation also exert a restraining influence. The study contributes to the literature by being the first to systematically assess the impact of new entrants on ESG greenwashing from the perspective of dynamic market structure and by introducing managerial confidence as a mediating mechanism. These findings offer a novel interpretive framework for understanding the strategic distortion of ESG initiatives and provide practical insights for policymakers seeking to combat greenwashing and for firms striving toward authentic green transformation under intensifying competition.
1
Executives with stronger environmental awareness or sustainability backgrounds, and firms with robust ESG disclosure mechanisms, partially mitigate competition-induced greenwashing.
2
Institutional investors’ site visits, media scrutiny, and government regulation restrain corporate ESG greenwashing.
3
Market competition is measured by city-industry new-firm registrations, while greenwashing is captured by the gap between ESG disclosure scores and actual performance ratings.
4
The effect of new entrants operates mainly through reduced managerial confidence and heightened managerial short-termism.
5
Using Chinese A-share listed-company data from 2009–2022, the study finds that new-firm entry significantly increases incumbent firms’ ESG greenwashing.

ESG greenwashing by incumbent enterprises among A-share listed companies in China

The influence of competitive pressure from newly entering firms on incumbent enterprises’ ESG greenwashing, including the mediating roles of managerial confidence and short-termism and the moderating effects of executive environmental awareness, ESG disclosure mechanisms, and external oversight

Publication Details
Publication Date
2025-10-25
Journal
Publisher
ISSN
Cited by
18
Access Type
Author Information
Authors
Yaya Su
Conghao Zhu
Khaldoon Albitar
Explore further
Open the scid.ai AI chat with a ready-made request: it will find papers on a similar topic and help build a literature review.
Find similar papers in the chat
Make a presentation
100%