Integrating techno-economic, socio-technical and political perspectives on national energy transitions: A meta-theoretical framework
Интеграция техноэкономической, социотехнической и политической перспектив национальных энергетических переходов: метатеоретическая концептуальная схема
2017-11-02
SCID: 54.1/st4qp827
Discuss with AI
meta-theoretical frameworknational energy transitionspolitical perspectivesocio-technical perspectivetechno-economic perspective
Figures from the paper
Abstract (AI)
Economic development, technological innovation, and policy change are especially prominent factors shaping energy transitions. Therefore explaining energy transitions requires combining insights from disciplines investigating these factors. The existing literature is not consistent in identifying these disciplines nor proposing how they can be combined. We conceptualize national energy transitions as a co-evolution of three types of systems: energy flows and markets, energy technologies, and energy-related policies. The focus on the three types of systems gives rise to three perspectives on national energy transitions: techno-economic with its roots in energy systems analysis and various domains of economics; socio-technical with its roots in sociology of technology, STS, and evolutionary economics; and political with its roots in political science. We use the three perspectives as an organizing principle to propose a meta-theoretical framework for analyzing national energy transitions. Following Elinor Ostrom's approach, the proposed framework explains national energy transitions through a nested conceptual map of variables and theories. In comparison with the existing meta-theoretical literature, the three perspectives framework elevates the role of political science since policies are likely to be increasingly prominent in shaping 21st century energy transitions.
Key Findings
1
A nested conceptual map of variables and theories, inspired by Elinor Ostrom, organizes explanations of national energy transitions across these perspectives.
2
Compared with existing meta-theoretical approaches, the framework gives greater prominence to political science because policies are expected to increasingly shape 21st-century energy transitions.
3
National energy transitions are conceptualized as the co-evolution of energy flows and markets, energy technologies, and energy-related policies.
4
The framework addresses inconsistencies in existing literature about which disciplines explain energy transitions and how their insights should be combined.
5
The framework integrates three perspectives: techno-economic, socio-technical, and political, each grounded in distinct disciplinary traditions.
Research Object
national energy transitions
Research Subject
the co-evolution of energy flows and markets, energy technologies, and energy-related policies, and the roles of techno-economic, socio-technical, and political factors in shaping these transitions
Publication Details
Publication Date
2017-11-02
Journal
Publisher
ISSN
Cited by
603
Open access PDF
Access Type
Author Information
Download PDF
Subscribe to digest