Negative-pressure wound therapy versus standard dressings for adults with an open lower limb fracture: the WOLLF RCT

Терапия ран отрицательным давлением по сравнению со стандартными повязками у взрослых с открытым переломом нижней конечности: рандомизированное контролируемое исследование WOLLF
Matthew L. Costa, Juul Achten, Julie Bruce, Sonia Davis, Susie Hennings, Keith Willett, Stavros Petrou, Steven Jeffery, Damian Griffin, Ben Parker, James Masters, Sarah E Lamb, Elizabeth Tutton, Nick Parsons
2018-12-01

Disability Rating Indexdeep infectionnegative-pressure wound therapyopen lower limb fracturerandomised controlled trial
Background Open fractures of the lower limb occur when a broken bone penetrates the skin and is exposed to the outside environment. These are life-changing injuries. The risk of deep infection may be as high as 27%. The type of dressing applied after surgical debridement could potentially reduce the risk of infection in the open-fracture wound. Objectives To assess the disability, rate of deep infection, quality of life and resource use in patients with severe open fracture of the lower limb treated with negative-pressure wound therapy (NPWT) versus standard wound management after the first surgical debridement of the wound. Design A pragmatic, multicentre randomised controlled trial. Setting Twenty-four specialist trauma hospitals in the UK Major Trauma Network. Participants A total of 460 patients aged ≥ 16 years with a severe open fracture of the lower limb were recruited from July 2012 through to December 2015. Patients were excluded if they presented more than 72 hours after their injury or were unable to complete questionnaires. Interventions Negative-pressure wound therapy (n = 226) where an ‘open-cell’ solid foam or gauze was placed over the surface of the wound and connected to a suction pump which created a partial vacuum over the dressing versus standard dressings not involving negative pressure (n = 234). Main outcome measures Disability Rating Index (DRI) – a score of 0 (no disability) to 100 (completely disabled) at 12 months was the primary outcome measure, with a minimal clinically important difference of 8 points. The secondary outcomes were deep infection, quality of life and resource use collected at 3, 6, 9 and 12 months post randomisaton. Results There was no evidence of a difference in the patients’ DRI at 12 months. The mean DRI in the NPWT group was 45.5 points [standard deviation (SD) 28.0 points] versus 42.4 points (SD 24.2 points) in the standard dressing group, giving a difference of –3.9 points (95% confidence interval –8.9 to 1.2 points) in favour of standard dressings (p = 0.132). There was no difference in HRQoL and no difference in the number of surgical site infections or other complications at any point in the 12 months after surgery. NPWT did not reduce the cost of treatment and it was associated with a low probability of cost-effectiveness. Limitations Owing to the emergency nature of the interventions, we anticipated that some patients who were randomised into the trial would subsequently be unable or unwilling to take part. Such post-randomisation withdrawal of patients could have posed a risk to the external validity of the trial. However, the great majority of these patients (85%) were found to be ineligible after randomisation. Therefore, we can be confident that the patients who took part were representative of the population with severe open fractures of the lower limb. Conclusions Contrary to the existing literature and current clinical guidelines, NPWT dressings do not provide a clinical or an economic benefit for patients with an open fracture of the lower limb. Future work Future work should investigate alternative strategies to reduce the incidence of infection and improve outcomes for patients with an open fracture of the lower limb. Two specific areas of potentially great benefit are (1) the use of topical antibiotic preparations in the open-fracture wound and (2) the role of orthopaedic implants with antimicrobial coatings when fixing the associated fracture. Trial registration Current Controlled Trials ISRCTN33756652 and UKCRN Portfolio ID 11783. Funding This project was funded by the National Institute for Health Research (NIHR) Health Technology Assessment programme and will be published in full inHealth Technology Assessment; Vol. 22, No. 73. See the NIHR Journals Library website for further project information.
1
Negative-pressure wound therapy showed no evidence of improving 12-month disability compared with standard dressings; mean DRI was 45.5 versus 42.4 points.
2
The WOLLF pragmatic multicentre randomized trial compared negative-pressure wound therapy with standard dressings after first debridement in 460 adults with severe open lower-limb fractures.
3
The abstract reports no evidence of a clinically important disability benefit from negative-pressure wound therapy over standard wound management.
4
The estimated between-group difference in 12-month Disability Rating Index was −3.9 points (95% CI −8.9 to 1.2), below the prespecified 8-point clinically important difference.
5
The trial evaluated deep infection, quality of life, and resource use alongside disability across 24 UK specialist trauma hospitals.

Severe open lower-limb fracture wounds in adults after the first surgical debridement

The comparative effects of negative-pressure wound therapy versus standard dressings on disability, deep infection, quality of life, and resource use

Publication Details
Publication Date
2018-12-01
Journal
Publisher
ISSN
Access Type
Author Information
Authors
Matthew L. Costa
Juul Achten
Julie Bruce
Sonia Davis
Susie Hennings
Keith Willett
Stavros Petrou
Steven Jeffery
Damian Griffin
Ben Parker
James Masters
Sarah E Lamb
Elizabeth Tutton
Nick Parsons
Explore further
Open the scid.ai AI chat with a ready-made request: it will find papers on a similar topic and help build a literature review.
Find similar papers in the chat →
Make a presentation
100%