Appeal to the Plots from the Historical past in the Writings of the “Founding Fathers” of the Old Believers and Their “Historical Erudition”

Обращение к историческим сюжетам в сочинениях «отцов-основателей» старообрядчества и их «историческая эрудиция»
Larisa D. Demidova
2024-04-28

Old Believer polemicsbook sourceschurch reformhistorical argumentationhistorical erudition
Proof by referring to past events is an important component of the early Old Believer polemics.Researchers have repeatedly paid attention to this feature.However, most often scientists were interested in the "big" historical concepts of the Old Believers, their interpretation of historical events in the light of eschatological theories.Much less often, they considered historical subjects that were used by the Old Believers in connection with polemics on certain issues, for example, of a dogmatic or moral nature.It seems that appealing to the entire set of arguments with examples from the past is important not only for identifying the reading range, the system of book authorities, and the origins of the ideology of the early Old Believers, but also for understanding the nature and specificity of the knowledge about the past possessed by its "founding fathers" had.In the context of controversy surrounding church reform in the 50-70s of the 17 th century Old Believer authors, sometimes forced to quickly resist innovations, first turned to sources already known to them, from which they could glean the necessary information about the past, and on this basis undertook a search for new data.Book sources for such examples, along with historical works themselves, were often works whose main function was not related to the transfer of purely historical knowledge.Information about the past was drawn from printed publications intended for religious education ("Kniga o vere", "Kirillova kniga"), and from Old Russian works of doctrinal and polemical content (Maxim the Greek, Iosif Volotskii), hagiographic oeuvres, sourse of canon law -Kormchaya kniga.This list of works is well known to researchers of the Old Believers in connection with the analysis of ideological issues.However, their role in the formation of the "historical erudition" of the defenders of the old rite is not so obvious.It seems that they were the full-fledged sources of more or less mass (to the extent that this was possible by the standards of the 17 th century) knowledge about the past, despite the fact that works of the historical genre had long and firmly taken their place in ancient Russian literature.This feature, it seems, should be taken into account when studying knowledge of the past shared of people of the 17 th century.
1
Analyzing the full range of historical examples can reveal Old Believer authors’ reading networks, authoritative books, ideological origins, and specific knowledge of the past.
2
During the 1650s–1670s church-reform controversy, Old Believer writers initially relied on familiar sources and subsequently searched for additional historical information to counter innovations.
3
Early Old Believer polemics used references to past events as a major form of proof, including in debates over dogmatic and moral issues.
4
Historical knowledge was drawn not only from historical works but also from religious-educational texts, doctrinal and polemical writings, hagiography, and canon-law sources.
5
Texts such as Kniga o vere, Kirillova kniga, works by Maxim the Greek and Joseph of Volokolamsk, hagiographic writings, and the Kormchaya kniga functioned as sources shaping the historical erudition of Old Believer defenders.

The writings of the founding fathers of the Old Believers and their use of historical sources in early Old Believer polemics

Appeals to past events and the formation and specificity of the founding fathers’ historical erudition in debates over the 17th-century church reform

Publication Details
Publication Date
2024-04-28
Journal
Publisher
ISSN
Cited by
0
Access Type
Author Information
Authors
Larisa D. Demidova
Explore further
Open the scid.ai AI chat with a ready-made request: it will find papers on a similar topic and help build a literature review.
Find similar papers in the chat
Make a presentation
100%