The Pivot: How Founders Respond to Feedback through Idea and Identity Work

Поворот: как основатели реагируют на обратную связь посредством работы с идеями и идентичностью
Matthew G. Grimes
2017-12-21

creative revisionentrepreneurial ideasexternal feedbackfounder identitypsychological ownership
Efforts to incorporate external feedback are central to the process of entrepreneurship and to that of creative work more broadly, yet, because individuals may view aspects of their creative ideas as linked to their self-concepts, this can trigger resistance toward revision. Thus, feedback-induced change, while likely intended to increase the viability of creative ideas, might paradoxically undermine that viability by compromising creative workers’ associated identity-based relationships with their creative endeavors. While existing scholarship has established the importance of creative revision, research has largely overlooked how this vital process intersects with creative workers’ identities. Through a field study of 59 founders and their entrepreneurial ideas, I present an identity-based process model of creative revision that highlights differences in founders’ psychological ownership of their ideas and how those differences affect subsequent revision efforts. The emerging findings contribute to existing theory by revealing that the capacity to extend the novelty and usefulness of one’s ideas is not merely subject to informational constraints but also to identity-based constraints.
1
A field study of 59 founders develops an identity-based process model explaining how psychological ownership of ideas shapes subsequent revision efforts.
2
Feedback-induced revision of entrepreneurial ideas can provoke resistance when founders perceive their ideas as connected to their self-concepts.
3
Founders’ differing levels of psychological ownership influence how they respond to external feedback and undertake creative revision.
4
Revising ideas to improve viability may paradoxically undermine viability when it damages founders’ identity-based relationships with their creative work.
5
The ability to extend an idea’s novelty and usefulness is constrained not only by available information but also by identity-related factors.

founders and their entrepreneurial ideas

identity-based creative revision processes, including how psychological ownership shapes responses to external feedback and the extension of idea novelty and usefulness

Publication Details
Publication Date
2017-12-21
Journal
Publisher
ISSN
Cited by
393
Access Type
Author Information
Authors
Matthew G. Grimes
Explore further
Open the scid.ai AI chat with a ready-made request: it will find papers on a similar topic and help build a literature review.
Find similar papers in the chat →
Make a presentation
100%