An Assessment of the Impact of the Protection Zone Regime for Cultural Heritage Sites on the Value of Land for Individual Housing Construction in the Context of a Low-Activity Market
Оценка влияния режима зон охраны объектов культурного наследия на стоимость земель для индивидуального жилищного строительства в условиях низкоактивного рынка
2024-05-26
SCID: 54.1/uas5p23e
Discuss with AI
comparative sales analysiscultural heritage protection zonesindividual housing constructionland valuationlow-activity real estate market
Figures from the paper
Abstract (AI)
The preservation of cultural heritage plays a key role in the development of society. To preserve cultural heritage, protection zones are established, which represent an encumbrance on land plots and, therefore, should be taken into account in the valuation process. Currently, there is a problem that mass (cadastral) and individual valuation methods do not necessarily include cultural heritage objects and their zones in cost coefficients. The absence of a mechanism to address their individual characteristics in the real estate valuation system has a significant impact on the value of real estate and leads to unjustifiably inflated market value and, as a consequence, to disputing the results of cadastral valuation. This article is devoted to determining the impact of protection zones of cultural heritage objects on the value of land intended for individual housing construction, using the example of the city of Orenburg. This article considers various methods of identifying patterns of the influence of zones with special conditions of use of the territory on the market value of land and substantiates the use of the method of comparative sales in the conditions of a low-active land market in Orenburg, a statistical analysis of market information, on the basis of which the type of activity of the real estate market in Orenburg was determined. The patterns of the calculation of corrections for the remoteness of the studied land plots from the objects of the transport and social infrastructure of Orenburg were revealed in this work as well. Through the method of paired sales within the framework of an individual assessment of the land plot intended for individual housing construction, the diminishing impact of the zones of protection of cultural heritage objects on the market value of land plots was revealed. This allows for conclusions to be drawn as to whether objects of cultural heritage have an impact on the value of real estate, and as a result, there is a need to modify the applied methods of mass and individual real estate valuation within the boundaries of historical settlements.
Key Findings
1
Cultural heritage protection zones act as land-use encumbrances that should be incorporated into both cadastral and individual real-estate valuation.
2
For Orenburg’s low-activity land market, the study substantiates comparative-sales analysis supported by statistical assessment of market activity.
3
Paired-sales analysis shows that cultural heritage protection zones have a diminishing effect on the market value of land plots intended for individual housing construction.
4
The omission of heritage objects and their protection zones from valuation coefficients can produce unjustifiably inflated property values and trigger disputes over cadastral assessments.
5
The study identifies adjustment patterns for land-plot distance from Orenburg’s transport and social infrastructure.
Research Object
Land plots intended for individual housing construction in protection zones of cultural heritage sites in Orenburg
Research Subject
The impact of cultural heritage protection-zone encumbrances on the market value of individual-housing land plots in a low-activity market
Publication Details
Publication Date
2024-05-26
Journal
Publisher
ISSN
Cited by
5
Open access PDF
Access Type
Author Information
Download PDF
Subscribe to digest
References available in scid.ai6
Credibility of the cadastral data on land use and the methodology for their verification and update2021
Property Mass Valuation on Small Markets2021
Modeling the Size of Protection Zones of Cultural Heritage Sites Based on Factors of the Historical and Cultural Assessment of Lands2021
Cadastral valuation of forest lands, taking into account the degree of development of their infrastructure2021
SPATIAL ANALYSIS OF SUBWAY PASSENGER TRAFFIC IN SAINT PETERSBURG2021
WORLD HERITAGE DESIGNATION AND PROPERTY: THE IMPACT OF PRESERVATION ON THE PRICE OF HISTORIC ASSETS2022