The relationship between international humanitarian and human rights law where it matters: admissible killing and internment of fighters in non-international armed conflicts
Взаимосвязь международного гуманитарного права и права прав человека там, где это имеет значение: допустимость убийства и интернирования комбатантов в немеждународных вооружённых конфликтах
2008-09-01
SCID: 54.1/ukqpruss
Discuss with AI
international human rights lawinternational humanitarian lawinternment of fighterslex specialis principlenon-international armed conflicts
Figures from the paper
Abstract (AI)
Abstract This article explores the relationship between international humanitarian and human rights law during non-international armed conflict. It seeks to answer two questions which are crucial in practice, but where the relationship between the two branches and the answers of humanitarian law alone are unclear. First, according to which branch of law may a member of an armed group be attacked and killed? Second, may a captured member of an armed force or group be detained similarly to a prisoner of war in international armed conflicts or as prescribed by human rights? Through application of the lex specialis principle, this article discusses possible answers to these questions.
Key Findings
1
It applies the lex specialis principle to determine which legal regime governs the targeting and killing of armed-group members.
2
It highlights unresolved practical questions where neither the relationship between the two legal branches nor humanitarian law alone provides clear answers.
3
The analysis addresses whether captured members of armed forces or groups may be interned similarly to prisoners of war in international armed conflicts.
4
The article compares humanitarian-law rules with human-rights requirements concerning detention in non-international armed conflicts.
5
The article examines how international humanitarian law and human rights law interact during non-international armed conflicts.
Research Object
members of armed groups or forces in non-international armed conflicts
Research Subject
the legal basis and conditions for admissible killing and internment of captured fighters under the relationship between international humanitarian law and human rights law
Publication Details
Publication Date
2008-09-01
Journal
Publisher
ISSN
Open access PDF
Access Type
Author Information
Download PDF
Subscribe to digest