Ten questions concerning soundscape valuation

Десять вопросов об оценке звукового ландшафта
Jian Kang, A Bristow, Hilary Notley, Francesco Aletta, John Nellthorp, Like Jiang, Rhian Thomas, A. D. Thomas
2022-05-25

cost-benefit analysisenvironmental valuationnoise managementsoundscape valuationsoundscape-based CBA
The past two decades have seen an ongoing paradigm shift from noise control to soundscaping, and soundscape approaches have been applied in noise management projects. However, cost-benefit analysis (CBA), which is widely used for economic appraisal of projects that would impact on the sound environment, remains noise-based and residential-location-focused. As a result, benefits of wanted sounds are omitted from appraisal. While there is a wealth of literature seeking to place a value/cost on changes in noise exposure, little research has been done on soundscape valuation. Consequently, there is little evidence on the monetary value of soundscape, which is essential for developing soundscape-based CBA. This paper initiates a systematic discussion on this emerging topic, by addressing ten questions covering the definition and scope for soundscape valuation, potential valuation methods for primary soundscape valuation research and required data, special concerns on private and public contexts, non-monetary valuation and soundscapes of cultural and/or historical significance, and the eventual application of soundscape values in CBA and beyond. Answers are based on reflection of existing literature on environmental valuation and soundscape, and visionary opinions by the authors from research, practice and policy sectors, and can help establish a framework to support future research in soundscape valuation and relevant areas.
1
Current cost-benefit analyses omit the benefits of wanted sounds because they lack monetary values for soundscape changes.
2
Research on soundscape valuation is limited compared with the extensive literature valuing noise exposure, creating an evidence gap for soundscape-based appraisal.
3
Soundscape approaches are increasingly used in noise management, but economic appraisal remains predominantly noise-based and focused on residential locations.
4
The paper structures a systematic discussion around ten questions covering valuation definitions, methods, data needs, private and public contexts, non-monetary values, cultural significance, and CBA applications.
5
The proposed framework is intended to guide future research and support the integration of soundscape values into cost-benefit analysis and related policy applications.

soundscape valuation in environmental and economic appraisal contexts

the monetary and non-monetary value of soundscapes, including valuation scope, methods, data needs, contextual concerns, and application in cost-benefit analysis

Publication Details
Publication Date
2022-05-25
Journal
Publisher
ISSN
Cited by
42
Access Type
Author Information
Authors
Jian Kang
A Bristow
Hilary Notley
Francesco Aletta
John Nellthorp
Like Jiang
Rhian Thomas
A. D. Thomas
Explore further
Open the scid.ai AI chat with a ready-made request: it will find papers on a similar topic and help build a literature review.
Find similar papers in the chat
Make a presentation
100%