Who is better in project planning?Generative artificial intelligence or project managers?

Кто лучше планирует проекты: генеративный искусственный интеллект или менеджеры проектов?
André Barcauí, André Monat
2023-11-04

Digital technology sectorGPT-4Generative artificial intelligenceProject planningPrompt engineering
This paper presents a comparative study of generative artificial intelligence (AI), specifically the GPT-4 model, and a human project manager in the context of a project plan development. The study's objective was to analyze the content and structure of a project plan prepared by this disruptive new technology and its human counterpart, focusing on the digital technology sector. Through a primarily qualitative methodology, the study scrutinizes critical aspects of each part of the project plan, including scope preparation, schedule development, cost estimation, resources evaluation, quality planning, stakeholder mapping, communication planning, and risk analysis. The results indicate unique strengths and weaknesses for both AI-generated and human-generated project plans, revealing them as complementary in the project planning process. It also emphasizes the continued importance of human expertise in refining AI outputs and harnessing the full potential of AI through the process known as prompt engineering. In conclusion, this study illustrates the potential synergy between human experience and AI in project planning, suggesting the careful integration of human and AI capabilities is key to developing robust and trustworthy project plans.
1
AI-generated and human-generated plans exhibit distinct strengths and weaknesses rather than one approach being universally superior.
2
Human expertise remains important for refining AI-generated outputs, while prompt engineering helps harness AI’s project-planning capabilities.
3
The comparison evaluates scope, scheduling, cost, resources, quality, stakeholders, communications, and risks using a primarily qualitative methodology.
4
The findings support integrating human experience and generative AI complementarily to create more robust and trustworthy project plans.
5
The study compares GPT-4 and a human project manager in developing project plans for the digital technology sector.

project plans for digital technology projects developed by GPT-4 and a human project manager

comparative content and structural quality of project planning, including scope, schedule, cost, resources, quality, stakeholders, communication, and risks

Publication Details
Publication Date
2023-11-04
Journal
Publisher
ISSN
Access Type
Author Information
Authors
André Barcauí
André Monat
Explore further
Open the scid.ai AI chat with a ready-made request: it will find papers on a similar topic and help build a literature review.
Find similar papers in the chat →
Make a presentation
100%