Comparison of Biochemical and Physiological Properties of Two Brassica Microgreens Cultivated in Two Growth Systems

Сравнение биохимических и физиологических свойств двух микрозелёных Brassica, выращенных в двух системах культивации
Christophe El‐Nakhel, Giandomenico Corrado, Michele Ciriello, Giovanna Marta Fusco, Petronia Carillo, Youssef Rouphael
2026-02-02

Brassica microgreensgrowth substrate (peat) vs substrate-free systemmibunaorganic acid metabolism (malate, citrate)pak choi
Microgreens are promising crops for low-input systems, but the roles of species traits and root environments under uncontrolled greenhouse conditions are not yet fully addressed. In this study, mibuna and pak choi were evaluated in the presence or absence of substrate to clarify how genetic and physical factors shape growth and biochemical composition. Clear species-dependent differences emerged. Pak choi showed higher constitutive levels of chlorophyll a, anthocyanins, and key osmotic ions, and these features contributed to a more hydrated tissue profile. Mibuna instead exhibited a higher dry matter content, approximately 7% compared with 5.86% in pak choi, and a lighter canopy. The use of peat markedly improved overall growth. Fresh yield increased by more than 50%, and dry yield increased by almost 48% compared with the substrate-free system. Peat also enhanced organic acid metabolism, with malate and citrate increasing by 277 and 102%, respectively. Despite such differences, nitrate concentrations remained low and within safe limits for leafy vegetables in all treatments. The results indicate that species identity and the cultivation system significantly shaped overall microgreen performance under low-input conditions. Understanding these drivers provides a foundation for optimizing production while maintaining desirable nutritional traits.
1
Cultivation with peat substrate markedly improves growth: fresh yield increased by >50% and dry yield by ~48% versus substrate-free system.
2
Mibuna shows higher dry matter content (~7%) and a lighter canopy compared with pak choi (~5.86% dry matter).
3
Nitrate concentrations remained low and within safe limits for leafy vegetables across all species and cultivation systems.
4
Pak choi has higher constitutive levels of chlorophyll a, anthocyanins, and key osmotic ions, resulting in more hydrated tissue than mibuna.
5
Peat substrate strongly enhances organic acid metabolism, with malate and citrate increasing by 277% and 102%, respectively.
6
Species identity strongly affects microgreen biochemical and physiological traits under uncontrolled greenhouse conditions.

Two Brassica microgreen species (mibuna and pak choi) grown in two cultivation systems (with peat substrate and substrate-free) under uncontrolled greenhouse conditions

Comparison of biochemical and physiological properties and overall performance (growth, fresh and dry yield, tissue hydration, pigment and osmolyte levels, organic acid metabolism, and nitrate concentration) of the two Brassica microgreens as influenced by species identity and cultivation system

Publication Details
Publication Date
2026-02-02
Journal
Publisher
ISSN
Cited by
1
Access Type
Author Information
Authors
Christophe El‐Nakhel
Giandomenico Corrado
Michele Ciriello
Giovanna Marta Fusco
Petronia Carillo
Youssef Rouphael
Explore further
Open the scid.ai AI chat with a ready-made request: it will find papers on a similar topic and help build a literature review.
Find similar papers in the chat
Make a presentation
100%