Attitudes of doctors and nurses towards incident reporting: a qualitative analysis

Отношение врачей и медсестёр к сообщению о инцидентах: качественный анализ
Sue Evans, Marilyn J Kingston, Brian James Smith, Jesia G. Berry
2004-07-01

adverse eventshealthcare professional attitudesincident reportingnear-missesreporting barriers
OBJECTIVES: (i) To examine attitudes of medical and nursing staff towards reporting incidents (adverse events and near-misses), and (ii) to identify measures to facilitate incident reporting. DESIGN: Qualitative study. In March 2002, semistructured questions were administered to five focus groups--one each for consultants, registrars, resident medical officers, senior nurses, and junior nurses. PARTICIPANTS AND SETTING: 14 medical and 19 nursing staff recruited using purposive sampling from three metropolitan public hospitals in Adelaide, South Australia. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: Attitudes and barriers to incident reporting; differences in reporting behaviour between disciplines; how to facilitate incident reporting. RESULTS: Cultural differences between doctors and nurses, identified using Triandis' theory of social behaviour, were found to underpin attitudes to incident reporting. Nurses reported more habitually than doctors due to a culture which provided directives, protocols and the notion of security, whereas the medical culture was less transparent, favoured dealing with incidents "in-house" and was less reliant on directives. Common barriers to reporting incidents included time constraints, unsatisfactory processes, deficiencies in knowledge, cultural norms, inadequate feedback, beliefs about risk, and a perceived lack of value in the process. CONCLUSIONS: Strategies to improve incident reporting must address cultural issues.
1
Common barriers to incident reporting include time constraints, unsatisfactory processes, deficiencies in knowledge, cultural norms, inadequate feedback, beliefs about risk, and perceived lack of value.
2
Cultural differences between doctors and nurses underpin attitudes to incident reporting, analyzed using Triandis' theory of social behaviour.
3
Medical culture is less transparent, prefers dealing with incidents 'in-house', and is less reliant on directives, reducing reporting.
4
Nurses report incidents more habitually than doctors due to a culture of directives, protocols and perceived security.
5
Strategies to improve incident reporting must specifically address cultural issues to be effective.

Attitudes of medical and nursing staff towards incident reporting (adverse events and near-misses)

Factors shaping and differentiating those attitudes and barriers to incident reporting, including cultural differences between doctors and nurses, reporting behaviours, and measures to facilitate reporting

Publication Details
Publication Date
2004-07-01
Journal
Publisher
ISSN
Cited by
338
Access Type
Author Information
Authors
Sue Evans
Marilyn J Kingston
Brian James Smith
Jesia G. Berry
Explore further
Open the scid.ai AI chat with a ready-made request: it will find papers on a similar topic and help build a literature review.
Find similar papers in the chat →
Make a presentation
100%