Digital Twins in Health Care: Ethical Implications of an Emerging Engineering Paradigm

Цифровые двойники в здравоохранении: этические последствия новой инженерной парадигмы
Filippo Santoni de Sio, Jeroen van den Hoven, Koen Bruynseels, Koen Bruynseels
2018-02-13

Data-driven healthcareDigital twinsEthical implicationsHuman enhancementPersonalized medicine
Personalized medicine uses fine grained information on individual persons, to pinpoint deviations from the normal. ‘Digital Twins’ in engineering provide a conceptual framework to analyse these emerging data-driven health care practices, as well as their implications for therapy, preventative care and human enhancement. Digital Twins stands for a specific engineering paradigm, where individual physical artefacts are paired with a digital model that dynamically reflects the status of that artefact. When applied to persons, Digital Twins are an emerging technology that builds in silico representations of an individual that dynamically reflect molecular status, physiological status and life style over time. We use Digital Twins as the hypothesis that one would be in the possession of very detailed bio-physical and lifestyle information of a person over time. This perspective redefines the concept of ‘normality’ or ‘health’, as a set of patterns that are regular for a particular individual, against the backdrop of patterns observed in the population. This perspective also will impact what is considered therapy and what is enhancement, as can be illustrated with the cases of the ‘asymptomatic ill’ and life extension via anti-ageing medicine. This changes are the consequence of how meaning is derived, in case measurement data is available. Moral distinctions namely will be based on patterns found in these data and the meanings that are grafted on these patterns. Ethical and societal implications of Digital Twins are explored. Digital Twins imply a data-driven approach to health care. This approach has the potential to deliver significant societal benefits, and can function as a social equalizer, by allowing for effective equalizing enhancement interventions. It can as well though be a driver for inequality, given the fact that a digital twin might not be an accessible technology for everyone, and given the fact that patterns identified across a population of digital twins can lead to segmentation and discrimination. This duality calls for governance as this emerging technology matures, including measures that ensure transparency of data usage and derived benefits, and data privacy.
1
Applying Digital Twins to healthcare could redefine normality and health as patterns specific to individuals, interpreted against population-level patterns.
2
Digital Twin data may blur distinctions between therapy and enhancement, illustrated by asymptomatic illness detection and anti-ageing life extension.
3
Digital Twins are framed as dynamic in silico representations integrating an individual’s molecular, physiological, and lifestyle data over time.
4
Digital Twins could produce societal benefits and equalizing interventions, but may also increase inequality because access to the technology may be uneven.
5
Moral distinctions increasingly depend on meanings assigned to patterns identified in extensive longitudinal measurement data.

Digital Twins applied to individual persons in health care

The ethical and societal implications of data-driven personalized health care, including changing concepts of normality, therapy, prevention, enhancement, and inequality

Publication Details
Publication Date
2018-02-13
Journal
Publisher
ISSN
Cited by
775
Access Type
Author Information
Authors
Filippo Santoni de Sio
Jeroen van den Hoven
Koen Bruynseels
Koen Bruynseels
Explore further
Open the scid.ai AI chat with a ready-made request: it will find papers on a similar topic and help build a literature review.
Find similar papers in the chat →
Make a presentation
100%