The Strategic Use of Liberal Internationalism: Libya and the UN Sanctions, 1992–2003

Стратегическое использование либерального интернационализма: Ливия и санкции ООН, 1992–2003 гг.
Ian Hurd
2005-07-01

International legitimacyLiberal internationalismLibyaSymbolic powerUN sanctions
The UN's sanctions against Libya became an issue of great controversy in the Security Council in the 1990s owing to competing interpretations of the central legal norms of international relations. The norms of due process, the presumption of innocence, and respect for international organizations (IOs) were defended by both sides, but for opposite ends. I use the contestation over norms and law at the Council to argue three broader themes about international politics: first, that states' perceptions about the legitimacy of international institutions is important in influencing state behavior; second, that this legitimacy creates powerful symbols in international relations that are strategically useful to states in the pursuit of their interests; and third, that the distribution of material power among states does not necessarily parallel the distribution of symbolic power, and so it is not uncommon for apparently strong states to be defeated by apparently weak ones when they fight over symbolic stakes. The norms of liberal internationalism are intersubjective resources useful in the strategic competition among states.
1
Institutional legitimacy generates powerful symbolic resources that states can strategically deploy to pursue their interests.
2
Material power and symbolic power may diverge, allowing apparently weaker states to defeat stronger states in conflicts over symbolic stakes.
3
States’ perceptions of international institutions’ legitimacy significantly influence their behavior during disputes over sanctions and international law.
4
The Security Council controversy over sanctions against Libya centered on competing interpretations of due process, presumption of innocence, and respect for international organizations.
5
The norms of liberal internationalism function as intersubjective resources in strategic competition among states.

UN sanctions against Libya in the UN Security Council, 1992–2003

Strategic contestation over the legitimacy, legal norms, and symbolic power of liberal internationalism in shaping state behavior and outcomes

Publication Details
Publication Date
2005-07-01
Journal
Publisher
ISSN
Cited by
180
Access Type
Author Information
Authors
Ian Hurd
Explore further
Open the scid.ai AI chat with a ready-made request: it will find papers on a similar topic and help build a literature review.
Find similar papers in the chat →
Make a presentation
100%