What defines an incisional hernia as ‘complex’: results from a Delphi consensus endorsed by the European Hernia Society (EHS)

Frederik Berrevoet, Yohann Renard, C. Arvieux, Guido Woeste, Filip Muysoms, Miguel Ángel García Ureña, S. Chintapatla, Andrew de Beaux, Marja A. Boermeester, Barbora East, Dominic Slade, Jared Torkington, Pilar Hernández-Granados, Manuel López‐Cano, Danny Rosin, Christine Gaarder, Mauro Podda, Alberto Aiolfi, Giampiero Campanelli, M. P. Simons, Hana Charvátová, Neil Smart, Giulia Montori, Stavros A. Antoniou, Monica Ortenzi, Ferdinando Agresta, Micaela Piccoli, Victor G. Radu, Ulrich A. Dietz, Cesare Stabilini, Alberto Sartori, Sara Capoccia Giovannini, Sonia Ribas, Emanuele Botteri, Mette Willaume Christoffersen, Ursula Dahlstrand, Hanna de la Croix, A Ferreira, Renè H Fortenly, Hakan Gök, Barbora Jíšová, Orest P. Laver, Orest Lerchuk, Manuel Mega, Kryspin Mitura, Andrè Oliva, Ulf Petersson, Peder Rogmark, Ana Senent-Boza, Stella Smith, Alexis Theodorou, Jaanna Vironen
2023-10-28

SCID:  54.1/zavrj6qb
A ‘complex’ hernia is often referred to in the published literature, yet has not been clearly defined to date. ‘Large’ and ‘giant’ may also be used to describe a complex incisional hernia indirectly1–3. Meanwhile, a ‘complex hernia’ in reference to the technical surgical challenge of abdominal wall repair is different from a ‘complex patient’, the latter relating more to a patient’s mental or physical health. Several risk scores have been developed and described in the literature2,4–6. Although hernia dimensions and defect characteristics alongside patient co-morbidities have demonstrated some correlation with poor surgical outcomes1,3, postoperative complications alone should not define complexity6,7. Slater et al.8 subsequently published criteria to define a complex abdominal wall hernia, comprising four categories: size and location, contamination/soft tissue condition, patient history/risk factors, and clinical scenario; three severity classes were defined, namely minor, moderate, and major. Although often referenced in publications, this definition has not been found to be an efficient working definition of a complex incisional hernia4,9. Furthermore, with increasing preoperative adjuncts and operative strategies available to manage incisional hernia6,10, and increased surgical specialization in the field2,10, a revised consensus definition is required.
Publication Details
Publication Date
2023-10-28
Journal
Publisher
ISSN
Access Type
Author Information
Authors
Frederik Berrevoet
Yohann Renard
C. Arvieux
Guido Woeste
Filip Muysoms
Miguel Ángel García Ureña
S. Chintapatla
Andrew de Beaux
Marja A. Boermeester
Barbora East
Dominic Slade
Jared Torkington
Pilar Hernández-Granados
Manuel López‐Cano
Danny Rosin
Christine Gaarder
Mauro Podda
Alberto Aiolfi
Giampiero Campanelli
M. P. Simons
Hana Charvátová
Neil Smart
Giulia Montori
Stavros A. Antoniou
Monica Ortenzi
Ferdinando Agresta
Micaela Piccoli
Victor G. Radu
Ulrich A. Dietz
Cesare Stabilini
Alberto Sartori
Sara Capoccia Giovannini
Sonia Ribas
Emanuele Botteri
Mette Willaume Christoffersen
Ursula Dahlstrand
Hanna de la Croix
A Ferreira
Renè H Fortenly
Hakan Gök
Barbora Jíšová
Orest P. Laver
Orest Lerchuk
Manuel Mega
Kryspin Mitura
Andrè Oliva
Ulf Petersson
Peder Rogmark
Ana Senent-Boza
Stella Smith
Alexis Theodorou
Jaanna Vironen
Explore More Research
Use the citation graph to discover related papers and expand your research horizons.
Click any node to explore
Download PDF
100%