A critical review of “Internet addiction” criteria with suggestions for the future

Критический обзор критериев «интернет-зависимости» с предложениями на будущее
Antonius J. van Rooij, Nicole Prause
2014-12-01

Griffith’s components modelInternet addictionTao et al. criteriaYoung’s Internet Addiction Test (IAT)neuroimaging for model building
AIMS: In the last 5 years a deluge of articles on the topic of Internet addiction (IA) has proposed many candidate symptoms as evidence of this proposed disease. We critically reviewed the current approach to the measurement and identification of this new excessive behavior syndrome. METHODS: Three popular models of IA were discussed: Griffith’s components model; Young’s Internet Addiction Test (IAT); and the criteria by Tao et al. (2010). We selected these models because they are widely cited and propose specific criteria for IA disorder. Our approach is not meant to provide an exhaustive review, but to discuss and critique the most salient trends in the field. RESULTS: The models of Internet addiction share some criteria, including feeling a loss of control over Internet use; ensuing psychological, social, or professional conflict or problems; and preoccupation when not using the Internet. Other criteria inconsistently mentioned include: mood management, tolerance, withdrawal, and craving/anticipation. The models studied here share the assumption that the Internet can produce a qualitative shift to a diseased state in humans. CONCLUSIONS: We critically discussed the above criteria and concluded that the evidence base is currently not strong enough to provide support for an Internet addiction disorder. Future research areas are suggested: (1) Focusing on common impaired dimensions, (2) exploring neuroimaging as a model building tool, and (3) identifying shifts in the rewarding aspects of Internet use. Given the lack of consensus on the subject of Internet addiction, a focus on problem behaviors appears warranted.
1
All reviewed models assume the Internet can produce a qualitative shift to a diseased state, an assumption questioned by the authors.
2
Current evidence is insufficient to support classification of Internet addiction as a disorder.
3
Given lack of consensus, researchers should prioritize studying problem behaviors rather than assuming an IA disorder diagnosis.
4
Other proposed IA criteria are inconsistently applied across models: mood management, tolerance, withdrawal, and craving/anticipation.
5
Popular IA models (Griffith’s components, Young’s IAT, Tao et al.) share criteria: loss of control, conflict/problems, and preoccupation.
6
Recommended future research directions: focus on common impaired dimensions, use neuroimaging for model building, and identify shifts in rewarding aspects of Internet use.

Proposed diagnostic criteria/models for Internet addiction (Griffith’s components model, Young’s IAT, Tao et al. criteria)

Critical evaluation of those criteria/models regarding symptoms (loss of control, conflict, preoccupation, mood management, tolerance, withdrawal, craving), the assumption of a qualitatively diseased state, and recommendations for future research directions

Publication Details
Publication Date
2014-12-01
Journal
Publisher
ISSN
Cited by
233
Access Type
Author Information
Authors
Antonius J. van Rooij
Nicole Prause
Explore further
Open the scid.ai AI chat with a ready-made request: it will find papers on a similar topic and help build a literature review.
Find similar papers in the chat →
Make a presentation
100%