Why bioethics needs a concept of vulnerability

Почему биоэтике нужна концепция уязвимости
C. Paul Rogers, Mackenzie, Dodds
2012-01-01

autonomybioethicspublic health ethicsresearch ethicsvulnerability
Concern for human vulnerability seems to be at the heart of bioethical inquiry, but the concept of vulnerability is under-theorized in the bioethical literature. The aim of this article is to show why bioethics needs an adequately theorized and nuanced conception of vulnerability. We first review approaches to vulnerability in research ethics and public health ethics, and show that the bioethical literature associates vulnerability with risk of harm and exploitation, and limited capacity for autonomy. We identify some of the challenges emerging from this literature: in particular, how to reconcile universal human vulnerability with a context-sensitive analysis of specific kinds and sources of vulnerability; and how to reconcile obligations to protect vulnerable persons with obligations to respect autonomy. We then briefly survey some of the theoretical resources available within the philosophical literature to address these challenges, and to assist in understanding the conceptual connections between vulnerability and related concepts such as harm, exploitation, needs, and autonomy. We also sketch out a taxonomy of sources and kinds of vulnerability. Finally, we consider the implications for policy evaluation of making vulnerability an explicit and central focus of bioethics. Our investigation is in the form of a broad survey motivating a research agenda rather than a detailed analysis.
1
Bioethical literature commonly links vulnerability to risk of harm and exploitation and to limited capacity for autonomy.
2
Developing a nuanced conceptual framework (including a taxonomy of sources and kinds of vulnerability) would inform policy evaluation and motivates a research agenda.
3
Tensions exist between treating vulnerability as universal human condition and conducting context-sensitive analyses of specific vulnerabilities.
4
The concept of vulnerability is central to bioethical inquiry but remains under-theorized in bioethics literature.
5
There is a need to reconcile obligations to protect vulnerable persons with obligations to respect their autonomy.

The concept of vulnerability in bioethics

The need for an adequately theorized and nuanced conception of vulnerability, including its relations to harm, exploitation, autonomy, sources/kinds of vulnerability, and implications for research/public-health ethics and policy evaluation

Publication Details
Publication Date
2012-01-01
Journal
Publisher
ISSN
Cited by
93
Access Type
Author Information
Authors
C. Paul Rogers
Mackenzie
Dodds
Explore further
Open the scid.ai AI chat with a ready-made request: it will find papers on a similar topic and help build a literature review.
Find similar papers in the chat →
Make a presentation
100%