Urban historic heritage buffer zone delineation: the case of Shedian

Делимитация буферной зоны исторического городского наследия: на примере Шэдяня
Yiping Liu, Ruobing Lv, Ling Zhang, Dezheng Kong, Yiping Liu
2022-05-23

buffer zone delineationcultural heritage value assessmentheritage buffer zoneshistoric townsmulti-criteria decision-making
Abstract Buffer zones help protect historical heritage sites’ integrity, authenticity, and sustainability, and thus are an essential measure for protecting such sites. Traditional buffer zone delineation considers mainly the urban texture, a rigid boundary, visual corridor construction, and other factors. A more direct approach is designating a rated outer periphery that includes historic properties as a buffer zone. However, boundaries determined by single-value orientation tend to omit protected objects. A buffer zone formed by boundary translation and enclosure will include many low-value areas in the protection scope, thereby wasting resources and affecting historic towns’ natural development, resulting in a severe contradiction between humanity and the earth. This paper proposes a new method for delimiting buffer zones. The method arises from the field that covers the value assessment of cultural heritage and from the principles of comprehensive protection, which combine cultural heritage’s tangible and intangible properties. We used 29 historical preservation plans as samples to obtain statistics on their protection content, selected natural and agriculture landscapes, architectural features, construction quality, number of stories in a building, building age, protection class, street pattern, historical elements, urban texture, cultural industry, and cultural elements according to the frequency of occurrence as the primary factors affecting a buffer zone’s boundary demarcation. These factors were weighed and evaluated by the multi-criteria decision-making method (MCDM) to create a comprehensive evaluation map for helping determine a buffer zone’s boundary. Using such method, we identified the value of historical heritage through employing the quantitative analysis method of MCDM. We also used the evaluation result to determine the buffer zone boundary objectively. This approach rectifies the problems found in previous studies, namely an incomplete accounting of all relevant factors and a lack of data; it also provides a definition of an historical heritage buffer zone.
1
Analysis of 29 historical preservation plans identified 12 frequently occurring boundary-determination factors, including landscape, architectural, historical, urban-texture, and cultural characteristics.
2
Applying quantitative MCDM-based value assessment is presented as a way to address incompleteness and excessive inclusiveness in previous delineation approaches.
3
The method weights these factors using multi-criteria decision-making to produce a comprehensive evaluation map and objectively determine the buffer-zone boundary.
4
The study proposes a comprehensive buffer-zone method integrating tangible and intangible heritage values with principles of holistic protection.
5
Traditional buffer-zone delineation can omit protected heritage objects or include extensive low-value areas, causing resource waste and constraining historic towns’ development.

Shedian’s urban historic heritage and its surrounding buffer zone

Objective, comprehensive delineation of the heritage buffer-zone boundary based on the assessed tangible and intangible heritage values and their influencing factors

Publication Details
Publication Date
2022-05-23
Journal
Publisher
ISSN
Cited by
40
Access Type
Author Information
Authors
Yiping Liu
Ruobing Lv
Ling Zhang
Dezheng Kong
Yiping Liu
Explore further
Open the scid.ai AI chat with a ready-made request: it will find papers on a similar topic and help build a literature review.
Find similar papers in the chat →
Make a presentation
100%