Multi-criteria decision-making in the adaptive reuse of historic buildings: a bibliometric and systematic review of practices in China

Многокритериальное принятие решений при адаптивном повторном использовании исторических зданий: библиометрический и систематический обзор практик в Китае
Hong‐Chun Li, Xiancheng Liu, Xipan Xiao, Congxiang Tian, Guoqing Zhu
2025-11-18

Analytic Hierarchy Processadaptive reusebibliometric analysishistoric buildingsmulti-criteria decision-making
This study integrates a systematic literature review (SLR, per PRISMA 2020) with bibliometric analysis to examine how Multi-Criteria Decision-Making (MCDM) is applied to the adaptive reuse of historic buildings in China – a context marked by acute urbanization – heritage tensions and concentrated use of decision tools. Fifty-five publications (2010 to 2025) from the Web of Science and Scopus were analyzed using VOSviewer to map research hotspots and a coding matrix to classify methodological approaches, building types, and regional focus. Findings indicate that the Analytic Hierarchy Process (AHP) remains dominant – often integrated with GIS and HBIM – while fuzzy logic supports the assessment of intangible heritage values. Research concentrates on traditional districts, industrial heritage, and vernacular dwellings, with marked clustering in the Yangtze and Pearl River Deltas. Three analytical dimensions (technological/methodological, institutional/governance, and socio-cultural/landscape), together with five regeneration pathways, are synthesized to reveal the evolving logic of heritage reuse. At the corpus level, evidence points to east coast concentration and variable reporting of participation and reproducibility. Future work should broaden regional coverage, standardize reporting, such as weight derivation and sensitivity checks, and advance integration of GIS and HBIM with social data and policy targets, including carbon neutrality and rural revitalization, within MCDM frameworks.
1
Analytic Hierarchy Process remains the dominant MCDM method, frequently integrated with GIS and HBIM, while fuzzy logic addresses intangible heritage values.
2
Participation and reproducibility are reported inconsistently; future research should expand regional coverage, standardize weight derivation and sensitivity reporting, and integrate social data and policy goals such as carbon neutrality and rural revitalization.
3
Research primarily examines traditional districts, industrial heritage, and vernacular dwellings, with strong geographic concentration in the Yangtze and Pearl River Deltas and eastern China.
4
The review analyzed 55 publications from 2010–2025, combining PRISMA-based systematic review and bibliometric mapping of MCDM in China’s historic-building adaptive reuse.
5
The synthesis identifies technological/methodological, institutional/governance, and socio-cultural/landscape dimensions, alongside five adaptive-reuse regeneration pathways.

Adaptive reuse of historic buildings in China

Application, methodological patterns, and evolving analytical dimensions of multi-criteria decision-making for heritage reuse, including technological, institutional, socio-cultural, and landscape considerations

Publication Details
Publication Date
2025-11-18
Journal
Publisher
ISSN
Cited by
11
Access Type
Author Information
Authors
Hong‐Chun Li
Xiancheng Liu
Xipan Xiao
Congxiang Tian
Guoqing Zhu
Explore further
Open the scid.ai AI chat with a ready-made request: it will find papers on a similar topic and help build a literature review.
Find similar papers in the chat →
Make a presentation
100%