Impulsivity in Gambling Disorder and problem gambling: a meta-analysis

Импульсивность при расстройстве, связанном с азартными играми, и проблемном (рисковом) азартном поведении: метаанализ
Konstantinos Ioannidis, Roxanne W. Hook, Jon Edgar Grant, Samuel Robin Chamberlain, Katie Wickham
2019-04-15

Gambling Disorderattentional inhibitiondecision-makingimpulsivitymotor inhibition
Gambling Disorder is a prevalent psychiatric condition often linked to dysfunction of cognitive domains regulating impulsive behavior. Despite the centrality of impulsivity to neurobiological models of Gambling Disorder, a comprehensive meta-analysis of all impulsive cognitive domains has yet to be conducted. It is also not clear whether cognitive deficits in Gambling Disorder extend to those with problem (at-risk) gambling. A systematic review was undertaken of case-control studies examining the following cognitive domains in Gambling Disorder or in at-risk (problem) gambling: attentional inhibition, motor inhibition, discounting, decision-making, and reflection impulsivity. Case-control differences in cognition were identified using meta-analysis (random-effects modeling). Moderation analysis explored potential influences of age, gender, presence/absence of comorbidities in cases, geographical region, and study quality on cognitive performance. Gambling Disorder was associated with significant impairments in motor (g = 0.39-0.48) and attentional (g = 0.55) inhibition, discounting (g = 0.66), and decision-making (g = 0.63) tasks. For problem gambling, only decision-making had sufficient data for meta-analysis, yielding significant impairment versus controls (g = 0.66); however, study quality was relatively low. Insufficient data were available for meta-analysis of reflection impulsivity. There was evidence for significant publication bias only for the discounting domain, after an outlier study was excluded. Study quality overall was reasonable (mean score 71.9% of maximum), but most studies (~85%) did not screen for comorbid impulse control and related disorders. This meta-analysis indicates heightened impulsivity across a range of cognitive domains in Gambling Disorder. Decision-making impulsivity may extend to problem (at-risk) gambling, but further studies are needed to confirm such candidate cognitive vulnerability markers.
1
Gambling Disorder is associated with significant impairments in motor inhibition (effect sizes g = 0.39–0.48).
2
Gambling Disorder shows significant deficits in attentional inhibition (g = 0.55), discounting (g = 0.66), and decision-making (g = 0.63).
3
Insufficient data prevented meta-analysis of reflection impulsivity in both Gambling Disorder and problem gambling.
4
Problem (at-risk) gambling demonstrates significant decision-making impairment versus controls (g = 0.66), though study quality was relatively low.
5
Publication bias was evident only in the discounting domain after excluding an outlier; most studies (~85%) did not screen for comorbid impulse-control disorders.

Individuals with Gambling Disorder and with problem (at-risk) gambling

Impulsivity across cognitive domains (attentional inhibition, motor inhibition, discounting, decision-making, reflection impulsivity) as measured by case-control studies and meta-analytic effect sizes

Publication Details
Publication Date
2019-04-15
Journal
Publisher
ISSN
Cited by
340
Access Type
Author Information
Authors
Konstantinos Ioannidis
Roxanne W. Hook
Jon Edgar Grant
Samuel Robin Chamberlain
Katie Wickham
Explore further
Open the scid.ai AI chat with a ready-made request: it will find papers on a similar topic and help build a literature review.
Find similar papers in the chat →
Make a presentation
100%