Does regulatory impact assessment lead to better policy?

Приводит ли оценка регулирующего воздействия к улучшению государственной политики?
Peter J. Carroll
2010-04-07

OECD countriesevidence-based policypolicy development processesregulatory impact assessmentregulatory quality
Abstract Regulatory impact assessment systems bring evidence to bear on how to improve the quality of new or modified regulations. In the last 30 years they have become increasingly common in OECD countries. Regulatory proposals put forward by government agencies are now required to have a firm evidence base that clearly supports the new or modified regulation. However, in all jurisdictions actual practice has shown that the performance of the impact assessment systems has been very limited, with proposed regulation continuing to offer little in the way of a rigorous and convincing evidence base. This paper explores the reasons for the poor performance of evidence-based approaches. Reasons include the varying levels of ministerial and head of department/agency commitment, poor integration of impact assessment systems with existing policy development processes, variable capacity for rigorous, evidence-based policy in departments, and a lack of data on which evidence-based policy can be developed.
1
Despite formal requirements for strong evidence, regulatory proposals generally continue to lack rigorous and convincing supporting analysis.
2
Impact assessment systems perform poorly partly because of inconsistent commitment from ministers and senior departmental or agency leaders.
3
Insufficient data further limits the development of rigorous evidence-based policy.
4
Poor integration with existing policy-development processes and variable departmental capacity constrain evidence-based regulatory policymaking.
5
Regulatory impact assessment systems have become widespread in OECD countries over the past 30 years.

Regulatory impact assessment systems for proposed new or modified regulations

The performance of evidence-based regulatory impact assessment in improving policy quality and the factors underlying its limitations

Publication Details
Publication Date
2010-04-07
Journal
Publisher
ISSN
Cited by
51
Access Type
Author Information
Authors
Peter J. Carroll
Explore further
Open the scid.ai AI chat with a ready-made request: it will find papers on a similar topic and help build a literature review.
Find similar papers in the chat →
Make a presentation
100%