Diffusion without convergence: how political context shapes the adoption of regulatory impact assessment

Распространение без конвергенции: как политический контекст формирует внедрение оценки регулирующего воздействия
Claudio Maria Radaelli
2005-09-07

European Unionpolicy diffusionpolitical contextregulatory governanceregulatory impact assessment
Regulatory impact assessment (RIA) has emerged on the political agenda of the member states of the European Union (EU). RIA is the cornerstone of programmes for ‘better regulation’ and ‘good regulatory governance’. This article argues that the diffusion of RIA has not produced convergence. The lack of convergence is explained by the different political contexts – measured in terms of types of bureaucracy, government's capacity to handle distributional conflict, policy processes, and actors' preferences. These findings stand in contrast to the explanation for the adoption of regulatory policy tools based on the need to protect efficient markets. EU governments adopt RIA for a variety of reasons, and consequently the outcomes of the diffusion process differ markedly. Further, the evidence shows that ideas can travel more easily than the content of policy tools – a result at odds with the notion that changes in policy ideas are the most fundamental type of policy change. However, when ideas travel lightly, they may well stimulate the introduction of some instruments that are similarly labelled ‘impact assessment’, but RIA practice may exist only on paper, and in some cases basic assessments of administrative burdens are disguised under the RIA label. The diffusion of a common RIA ‘bottle’ has not produced similar ‘wines’.
1
Differences in bureaucracy, governmental capacity to manage distributional conflict, policy processes, and actor preferences explain divergent RIA adoption patterns.
2
EU governments adopt RIA for varied political reasons, challenging explanations centered primarily on protecting efficient markets.
3
In some countries, RIA exists largely on paper, with basic administrative-burden assessments sometimes presented under the RIA label.
4
Policy ideas travel more easily than the substantive content of policy tools, allowing similarly labelled RIA systems to differ markedly.
5
The diffusion of regulatory impact assessment across EU member states has not produced convergence in RIA practices or outcomes.

Regulatory impact assessment (RIA) adoption and practice in EU member states

How political contexts shape the diffusion, adoption, implementation, and divergent outcomes of RIA

Publication Details
Publication Date
2005-09-07
Journal
Publisher
ISSN
Cited by
346
Access Type
Author Information
Authors
Claudio Maria Radaelli
Explore further
Open the scid.ai AI chat with a ready-made request: it will find papers on a similar topic and help build a literature review.
Find similar papers in the chat →
Make a presentation
100%