EV versus ICE Vehicle Fires in Road Tunnels and Underground Garages: Literature-Based Parameters and Tenability Implications

Пожары электромобилей и автомобилей с двигателями внутреннего сгорания в дорожных тоннелях и подземных гаражах: параметры на основе литературных данных и последствия для условий пребывания людей
Marek Hnilica
2026-03-21

available safe egress timeelectric vehicle fireshydrogen fluoride toxicityinternal combustion engine fireslithium-ion battery thermal runaway
Electric vehicle (EV) fires represent a rapidly evolving safety challenge for enclosed subsurface infrastructures such as road tunnels and underground car parks. Unlike internal combustion engine (ICE) vehicle fires, lithium-ion battery incidents are characterised by thermal runaway, prolonged burning, and the release of toxic fluorinated gases. The results show that the available safe egress time (ASET) was 6 minutes for EV fires and 12 minutes for ICE fires, confirming a 50% reduction in evacuation safety margin. This study provides a comparative risk analysis of EV and ICE fire scenarios based on recent full-scale fire tests, peer-reviewed datasets published within the last three years, and a complementary simulation of temperature and toxic gas development over time. Key fire parameters were evaluated, including peak heat release rate, burning time, temperature distribution in the smoke layer, and concentrations of carbon monoxide (CO) and hydrogen fluoride (HF) relevant to human tenability limits and firefighter interventions. The results show that while peak heat release rates of EV fires are within the same order of magnitude as those of ICE vehicles, EV fires exhibit significantly longer burning phases, delayed peak temperatures, and HF concentrations capable of exceeding commonly accepted exposure thresholds even at low volumetric fractions. The prolonged fire duration, potential for re-ignition, and HF toxicity require revised operational tactics, including extended cooling strategies, mandatory respiratory and skin protection, and adapted evacuation timelines. The findings are intended to support tunnel operators, fire brigades, and civil protection authorities in updating emergency response plans for emerging EV-related fire hazards in confined underground environments.
1
Available safe egress time is 6 minutes for EV fires versus 12 minutes for ICE fires, representing a 50% reduction in evacuation safety margin.
2
EV and ICE fires have peak heat release rates within the same order of magnitude, but EV fires burn significantly longer and reach peak temperatures later.
3
EV fires can produce hydrogen fluoride concentrations exceeding commonly accepted exposure thresholds even at low volumetric fractions, creating severe tenability and firefighter risks.
4
The comparative assessment combines recent full-scale fire tests, peer-reviewed datasets from the last three years, and simulations of temperature and toxic-gas development in underground environments.
5
Thermal runaway, prolonged burning, and potential re-ignition in EV fires require extended cooling, mandatory respiratory and skin protection, and revised evacuation timelines.

EV and ICE vehicle fires in road tunnels and underground garages

Comparative fire behavior, toxic-gas development, and human tenability implications, including ASET, for EV versus ICE vehicle fires

Publication Details
Publication Date
2026-03-21
Journal
Acta Montanistica Slovaca
Publisher
Technical University of Košice
ISSN
1335-1788
Cited by
0
Access Type
Author Information
Authors
Marek Hnilica
Explore further
Open the scid.ai AI chat with a ready-made request: it will find papers on a similar topic and help build a literature review.
Find similar papers in the chat →
Make a presentation
100%