On the Disposition to Think Analytically: Four Distinct Intuitive-Analytic Thinking Styles

О склонности мыслить аналитически: четыре различных стиля интуитивно-аналитического мышления
Christie Newton, Justin R. Feeney, Gordon Pennycook
2023-03-02

Actively Open-minded ThinkingCOVID-19 misinformationCognitive Reflection Testbullshit receptivityintuitive-analytic thinking styles
Many measures have been developed to index intuitive versus analytic thinking. Yet it remains an open question whether people primarily vary along a single dimension or if there are genuinely different types of thinking styles. We distinguish between four distinct types of thinking styles: Actively Open-minded Thinking, Close-Minded Thinking, Preference for Intuitive Thinking, and Preference for Effortful Thinking. We discovered strong predictive validity across several outcome measures (e.g., epistemically suspect beliefs, bullshit receptivity, empathy, moral judgments), with some subscales having stronger predictive validity for some outcomes but not others. Furthermore, Actively Open-minded Thinking, in particular, strongly outperformed the Cognitive Reflection Test in predicting misperceptions about COVID-19 and the ability to discern between vaccination-related true and false news. Our results indicate that people do, in fact, differ along multiple dimensions of intuitive-analytic thinking styles and that these dimensions have consequences for understanding a wide range of beliefs and behaviors.
1
Actively Open-minded Thinking strongly outperforms the Cognitive Reflection Test in predicting COVID-19 misperceptions and distinguishing true from false vaccination-related news.
2
Different thinking-style subscales predict different outcomes more strongly, indicating that intuitive-analytic thinking is multidimensional rather than unidimensional.
3
Individual differences across multiple thinking-style dimensions help explain a broad range of beliefs and behaviors.
4
The four thinking-style dimensions show strong predictive validity across epistemically suspect beliefs, bullshit receptivity, empathy, and moral judgments.
5
The study identifies four distinct intuitive-analytic thinking styles: Actively Open-minded Thinking, Close-Minded Thinking, Preference for Intuitive Thinking, and Preference for Effortful Thinking.

intuitive-analytic thinking styles in people

the multidimensional structure of thinking styles and their predictive relationships with beliefs, judgments, empathy, and susceptibility to misinformation

Publication Details
Publication Date
2023-03-02
Journal
Publisher
ISSN
Access Type
Author Information
Authors
Christie Newton
Justin R. Feeney
Gordon Pennycook
Explore further
Open the scid.ai AI chat with a ready-made request: it will find papers on a similar topic and help build a literature review.
Find similar papers in the chat →
Make a presentation
100%