The role of analytic thinking in moral judgements and values

Роль аналитического мышления в моральных суждениях и ценностях
Derek J. Koehler, Nathaniel Barr, Gordon Pennycook, Jonathan Albert Fugelsang, James Allan Cheyne
2013-12-11

analytic thinkingcognitive abilitymoral foundationsmoral judgementsmoral values
While individual differences in the willingness and ability to engage analytic processing have long informed research in reasoning and decision making, the implications of such differences have not yet had a strong influence in other domains of psychological research. We claim that analytic thinking is not limited to problems that have a normative basis and, as an extension of this, predict that individual differences in analytic thinking will be influential in determining beliefs and values. Along with assessments of cognitive ability and style, religious beliefs, and moral values, participants judged the wrongness of acts considered disgusting and conventionally immoral, but that do not violate care- or fairness-based moral principles. Differences in willingness to engage analytic thinking predicted reduced judgements of wrongness, independent of demographics, political ideology, religiosity, and moral values. Further, we show that those who were higher in cognitive ability were less likely to indicate that purity, patriotism, and respect for traditions and authority are important to their moral thinking. These findings are consistent with a “Reflectionist” view that assumes a role for analytic thought in determining substantive, deeply-held human beliefs and values.
1
Higher cognitive ability was associated with placing less importance on purity, patriotism, tradition, and authority in moral thinking.
2
Individual differences in willingness to engage analytic thinking predicted reduced judgments that disgusting and conventionally immoral acts were wrong.
3
The findings support a Reflectionist view in which analytic thought contributes to substantive, deeply held beliefs and values beyond normative reasoning problems.
4
The relationship between analytic thinking and reduced wrongness judgments remained after controlling for demographics, political ideology, religiosity, and moral values.

Individual differences in analytic thinking (willingness and ability to engage analytic processing) in human participants

The influence of individual differences in analytic thinking and cognitive ability on moral judgements and the importance of moral values

Publication Details
Publication Date
2013-12-11
Journal
Publisher
ISSN
Cited by
195
Access Type
Author Information
Authors
Derek J. Koehler
Nathaniel Barr
Gordon Pennycook
Jonathan Albert Fugelsang
James Allan Cheyne
Explore further
Open the scid.ai AI chat with a ready-made request: it will find papers on a similar topic and help build a literature review.
Find similar papers in the chat →
Make a presentation
100%