Sympathetic Magical Thinking: The Contagion and Similarity “Heuristics”

Симпатическое магическое мышление: «эвристики» заражения и сходства
Paul Rozin, Carol Nemeroff
2002-07-08

contact and resemblancelaw of contagionlaw of similaritymagical thinkingsympathetic magic
THE LAWS OF SYMPATHETIC MAGIC The laws of sympathetic magic constitute a small but central subset of what might be called magical thinking . They share with the larger category that they promote beliefs about the world that are generally contrary to current scientific beliefs. However, unlike most other examples of magic, the laws of sympathetic magic do not necessarily invoke a sense of human or animate agency as a device to account for events in the world (see Nemeroff & Rozin, 2000; Tambiah, 1990, for a discussion of magical thinking in a broader context). In contrast to the larger category of magical thinking, the laws of sympathetic magic may be more tractable to experimental study for three reasons: (1) they are clearly defined; (2) they are present in abundance as modes of thought among contemporary people in developed societies; and (3) they invoke principles (e.g., contact, resemblance) that are easy to manipulate in the laboratory. Edwin Tylor (1879), James Frazer (1895), and Marcel Mauss (1902) proposed three laws of sympathetic magic that they took to be universal principles of thinking. The law of contagion holds that “once in contact, always in contact”; when objects make physical contact, essences may be permanently transferred. Thus, fingernail parings contain the “essence” of the person to whom they were previously attached, and foods carry the “essence” of those who prepared them. The law of similarity holds either that like causes like (causes resemble their effects) or appearance equals reality.
1
Sympathetic magic is defined as a central subset of magical thinking involving beliefs generally contrary to current scientific understanding.
2
The law of contagion holds that physical contact can permanently transfer an object's essence, while the law of similarity links resemblance between causes and effects or treats appearance as reality.
3
The laws of sympathetic magic are especially suitable for experimental study because they are clearly defined, widespread in contemporary developed societies, and based on experimentally manipulable principles.
4
Unlike many forms of magical thinking, sympathetic magic does not necessarily invoke human or animate agency to explain events.

Laws of sympathetic magic (contagion and similarity heuristics) as cognitive phenomena

the contagion and similarity heuristics governing beliefs that physical contact transfers essences and that resemblance links causes, effects, appearances, and reality

Publication Details
Publication Date
2002-07-08
Journal
Publisher
ISSN
Access Type
Author Information
Authors
Paul Rozin
Carol Nemeroff
Explore further
Open the scid.ai AI chat with a ready-made request: it will find papers on a similar topic and help build a literature review.
Find similar papers in the chat →
Make a presentation
100%