The evaluation illusion of large language models in medicine

Иллюзия оценки больших языковых моделей в медицине
Freya Gulamali, Irene Y. Chen, Monica Agrawal, Shalmali D. Joshi, Freya Gulamali, Monica Agrawal
2025-10-07

benchmark evaluationsclinical healthcareexperimental transparencylarge language modelsmedical evaluation
While large language models (LLMs) hold promise for transforming clinical healthcare, current comparisons and benchmark evaluations of large language models in medicine often fail to capture real-world efficacy. Specifically, we highlight how key discrepancies arising from choices of data, tasks, and metrics can limit meaningful assessment of translational impact and cause misleading conclusions. Therefore, we advocate for rigorous, context-aware evaluations and experimental transparency across both research and deployment.
1
Choices of evaluation data can create discrepancies that distort conclusions about medical LLM performance.
2
Medical LLM benchmarks and comparisons often fail to reflect real-world clinical efficacy and translational impact.
3
Metric selection can produce misleading assessments of LLM effectiveness in healthcare.
4
Task design and benchmark objectives may inadequately capture clinically meaningful capabilities.
5
The paper advocates rigorous, context-aware evaluation and experimental transparency in both research and deployment.

large language models in medicine

the validity and translational relevance of their evaluation, including the effects of data, task, and metric choices on assessed real-world efficacy

Publication Details
Publication Date
2025-10-07
Journal
Publisher
ISSN
Cited by
53
Access Type
Author Information
Authors
Freya Gulamali
Irene Y. Chen
Monica Agrawal
Shalmali D. Joshi
Freya Gulamali
Monica Agrawal
Explore further
Open the scid.ai AI chat with a ready-made request: it will find papers on a similar topic and help build a literature review.
Find similar papers in the chat →
Make a presentation
100%