Social virtue epistemology and epistemic exactingness
Социальная эпистемология добродетели и эпистемическая требовательность
2025-01-27
SCID: 54.1/ahdaavvm
Discuss with AI
epistemic environmentsepistemic exactingnessepistemic responsibilityepistemically significant conductsocial virtue epistemology
Figures from the paper
Abstract (AI)
Abstract Who deserves credit for epistemic successes, and who is to blame for epistemic failures? Extreme views, which would place responsibility either solely on the individual or solely on the individual’s surrounding environment, are not plausible. Recently, progress has been made toward articulating virtue epistemology as a suitable middle ground. A socio-environmentally oriented virtue epistemology can recognize that an individual’s traits play an important role in shaping what that individual believes, while also recognizing that some of the most efficacious individual traits have to do with how individuals structure their epistemic environments and how they respond to information received within these environments. I contribute to the development of such an epistemology by introducing and elucidating the virtue of epistemic exactingness, which is characterized by a motivation to regulate the epistemically significant conduct of others.
Key Findings
1
Epistemic exactingness expands accounts of epistemic responsibility by emphasizing interpersonal regulation of conduct as a source of epistemic success or failure.
2
Individual traits shape belief formation, but especially efficacious traits concern how people structure epistemic environments and respond to information within them.
3
The paper develops a socio-environmentally oriented virtue epistemology as a middle ground between purely individualistic and purely environmental accounts of epistemic responsibility.
4
The paper introduces epistemic exactingness as an epistemic virtue characterized by motivation to regulate the epistemically significant conduct of others.
Research Object
socio-environmentally oriented virtue epistemology
Research Subject
the virtue of epistemic exactingness, characterized by a motivation to regulate others’ epistemically significant conduct
Publication Details
Publication Date
2025-01-27
Journal
Publisher
ISSN
Cited by
3
Open access PDF
Access Type
Author Information
Download PDF
Subscribe to digest