The Efficacy of Methane Leak Detection and Repair (LDAR) Programs in Practice

Эффективность программ обнаружения и устранения утечек метана (LDAR) на практике
Matthew R. Johnson, David R. Tyner, Shona E. Wilde
2025-10-28

OGMP 2.0aerial methane surveysmethane leak detection and repairoptical gas imagingsource-resolved emissions
Periodic leak detection and repair (LDAR) surveys are a key part of most modern oil and gas sector methane regulations, however their effectiveness in real-world practice has been difficult to assess. This study analyzes three years of reported data from regulated LDAR surveys in British Columbia, Canada, which suggest that 3×/year optical gas imaging (OGI)-based LDAR surveys reduce detected emissions by half at fully compliant sites. However, independent source-resolved aerial surveys at an identical subset of sites find 12 times more methane emissions overall, and four times more emissions after conservatively excluding potential combustion-related and intentional vent sources not targeted by OGI LDAR surveys. This demonstrates that regulated OGI-based LDAR surveys only capture a small portion of total emissions in practice, raising concerns about overestimated mitigation impacts and potentially misguided expectations when assessing alternative technologies. Further analysis reveals the two methods find complementary subsets of sources, with aerial detections comprising a range of larger combustion, vent, and fugitive sources and LDAR detections dominated by numerous smaller leaks from connectors and valves. This underscores the importance of integrating complementary measurement approaches to capture the full distribution of emissions and the necessity of independent verification frameworks such as OGMP 2.0.
1
Aerial and LDAR methods identified complementary source populations: aerial surveys found larger combustion, vent, and fugitive sources, while LDAR primarily detected smaller connector and valve leaks.
2
After excluding potential combustion-related and intentional vent sources, aerial surveys still detected four times more emissions than OGI-based LDAR.
3
Independent source-resolved aerial surveys measured 12 times more methane emissions overall than regulated OGI-based LDAR surveys at identical sites.
4
The findings indicate that regulated OGI-based LDAR captures only a small fraction of total emissions, supporting complementary measurement approaches and independent verification frameworks such as OGMP 2.0.
5
Three-times-yearly optical gas imaging LDAR surveys reduced detected methane emissions by half at fully compliant British Columbia sites.

regulated oil and gas facilities in British Columbia, Canada, investigated through OGI-based LDAR surveys and independent source-resolved aerial surveys

the real-world efficacy and emission-capture completeness of OGI-based LDAR programs, including differences in detected source types and estimated methane mitigation

Publication Details
Publication Date
2025-10-28
Journal
Publisher
ISSN
Cited by
13
Access Type
Author Information
Authors
Matthew R. Johnson
David R. Tyner
Shona E. Wilde
Explore further
Open the scid.ai AI chat with a ready-made request: it will find papers on a similar topic and help build a literature review.
Find similar papers in the chat →
Make a presentation
100%