A review of close-range and screening technologies for mitigating fugitive methane emissions in upstream oil and gas
Обзор технологий ближнего действия и скрининга для снижения выбросов метана вследствие утечек на объектах добычи нефти и газа
2019-03-05
SCID: 54.1/4tzaqayh
Discuss with AI
comprehensive monitoring programfugitive methane emissionsleak detection and repairmethane screening technologiesoptical gas imaging
Figures from the paper
Abstract (AI)
Abstract Fugitive methane emissions from the oil and gas industry are targeted using leak detection and repair (LDAR) programs. Until recently, only a limited number of measurement standards have been permitted by most regulators, with emphasis on close-range methods (e.g. Method-21, optical gas imaging). Although close-range methods are essential for source identification, they can be labor-intensive. To improve LDAR efficiency, there has been a policy shift in Canada and the United States towards incorporating alternative technologies. However, the suitability of these technologies for LDAR remains unclear. In this paper, we systematically review and compare six technology classes for use in LDAR: handheld instruments, fixed sensors, mobile ground labs (MGLs), unmanned aerial vehicles (UAVs), aircraft, and satellites. These technologies encompass broad spatial and temporal scales of measurement. Minimum detection limits for technology classes range from <1 g h−1 for Method 21 instruments to 7.1 × 106 g h−1 for the GOSAT satellite, and uncertainties are poorly constrained. To leverage the diverse capabilities of these technologies, we introduce a hybrid screening-confirmation approach to LDAR called a comprehensive monitoring program. Here, a screening technology is used to rapidly tag high-emitting sites to direct close-range source identification. Currently, fixed sensors, MGLs, UAVs, and aircraft could be used as screening technologies, but their performances must be evaluated under a range of environmental and operational conditions to better constrain detection effectiveness. Methane-sensing satellites are improving rapidly and may soon be ready for facility-scale screening. We conclude with a speculative discussion of the future of LDAR, touching on integration, analytics, incentivization, and regulatory pathways.
Key Findings
1
Fixed sensors, mobile ground labs, UAVs, and aircraft are currently plausible screening technologies, but their effectiveness requires evaluation across diverse environmental and operational conditions.
2
Methane-sensing satellites are advancing rapidly and may soon support facility-scale screening, potentially broadening LDAR coverage.
3
Minimum detection limits vary by technology from below 1 g h−1 for Method 21 instruments to 7.1 × 10^6 g h−1 for GOSAT, while uncertainties remain poorly constrained.
4
The proposed comprehensive monitoring program combines rapid screening to identify high-emitting sites with close-range measurements for source localization and confirmation.
5
The review compares six LDAR technology classes spanning handheld instruments, fixed sensors, mobile ground labs, UAVs, aircraft, and satellites.
Research Object
Fugitive methane emissions from upstream oil and gas facilities and the technologies used for their detection and screening
Research Subject
The detection capabilities, measurement limits, uncertainties, spatial and temporal coverage, and suitability of close-range and alternative technologies for leak detection and repair (LDAR)
Publication Details
Publication Date
2019-03-05
Journal
Publisher
ISSN
Cited by
193
Open access PDF
Access Type
Author Information
Download PDF
Subscribe to digest
References available in scid.ai2
Cited by15
Methane Mitigation: Methods to Reduce Emissions, on the Path to the Paris Agreement2020
Methods for quantifying methane emissions using unmanned aerial vehicles: a review2021
Robust probabilities of detection and quantification uncertainty for aerial methane detection: Examples for three airborne technologies2023
Comparing Continuous Methane Monitoring Technologies for High-Volume Emissions: A Single-Blind Controlled Release Study2024
Point Sensor Networks Struggle to Detect and Quantify Short Controlled Releases at Oil and Gas Sites2024
Field Performance of New Methane Detection Technologies: Results from the Alberta Methane Field Challenge2021
A methane emissions reduction equivalence framework for alternative leak detection and repair programs2019
The Efficacy of Methane Leak Detection and Repair (LDAR) Programs in Practice2025
Intelligent monitoring of fugitive emissions – comparison of continuous monitoring with intelligent analytics to other emissions monitoring technologies2022
A Review of Source-Term Estimation for Continuous Methane Monitoring: From Data Acquisition to Modeling and Estimation2026
Methane emission detection, localization, and quantification using continuous point-sensors on oil and gas facilities2022
A Performance Evaluation Framework for Continuous Methane Monitoring: Effects of Event Association and Metric Choice2026
Assessment of the Fugitive Emission Distributed Sampling (FEDS) system: a mobile, multi-inlet system for continuous emissions monitoring2026
Single-blind test of airplane-based hyperspectral methane detection via controlled releases2021
Long Distance Continuous Methane Emissions Monitoring with Dual Frequency Comb Spectroscopy: deployment and blind testing in complex emissions scenarios2020