A Critical Review of the Status of SAGD: Where Are We and What Is Next?
Критический обзор состояния SAGD: где мы сейчас и что дальше?
2008-03-29
SCID: 54.1/b3ykz6vt
Discuss with AI
Steam Assisted Gravity Drainage (SAGD)heavy oil/bitumen recoverylaboratory-field scale inconsistencynumerical modelling challengesthermal recovery techniques
Figures from the paper
Abstract (AI)
Abstract With around 7 trillion barrels reserves and recent increase in oil demand, there is no doubt that there would be tremendous effort on the development of heavy-oil/bitumen (HO-B) reservoirs in the next decades. Yet the in-situ recovery of HO-B is still not a simple process and there are many technical challenges accompanied with it. Two major techniques, namely thermal and miscible, have been considered in the HO-B development, along with several other auxiliary methods (chemical, gas, electromagnetic heating etc.) for different well configurations, steam assisted gravity drainage (SAGD) being the most popular among others. Miscible techniques did not yet go to a high commercial level, while thermal techniques have by far a stable foundation in the industry. Despite remarkable amount of laboratory experiments and computational studies on the thermal techniques for HO-B, especially SAGD, there was no extensive and critical literature review of the knowledge gained over almost three decades. We believe that a critical review of the status of the SAGD process will fill the gap by shedding light on the deficiencies and limitations of the process, further development areas, and new research topics. Specific attention, in this paper, was given to (a) the effect of geological environment on the physics of the process, (b) evaluation of the laboratory scale procedure and results (reasons of residual oil saturation, is it well configuration or pore scale dynamics?) and the reasons of the inconsistency between the lab and field scale performances, (c) problems faced in numerical modelling (capturing the physics of the process, relative permeability curves, dynamics of gravity controlled counter-current flow), (d) evaluation of the pilot and commercial level field applications, and (e) operational and technical challenges. It is believed that a good compilation of the records produced over three decades will constitute a useful reference for the industry and academic people.
Key Findings
1
Heavy-oil/bitumen reservoirs (~7 trillion barrels) will drive extensive HO-B development, but in-situ recovery remains technically challenging.
2
Key unresolved issues for SAGD include geological controls on process physics, scale discrepancies between lab and field residual oil saturation, and pore-scale versus well-configuration effects.
3
Numerical modelling challenges persist for SAGD, notably capturing process physics, accurate relative permeability curves, and gravity-controlled counter-current flow dynamics.
4
There is a lack of an extensive, critical literature review synthesizing three decades of laboratory, computational, pilot, and field knowledge on SAGD.
5
Thermal techniques, particularly SAGD, are the most established commercial approach for HO-B recovery; miscible techniques have not reached high commercial adoption.
Research Object
Steam Assisted Gravity Drainage (SAGD) process for heavy-oil/bitumen in-situ recovery
Research Subject
Status, deficiencies, limitations, and future development needs of SAGD including effects of geological environment, lab-to-field scale discrepancies (residual oil saturation and well vs pore-scale dynamics), numerical modelling challenges (physics capture, relative permeability, gravity-driven counter-current flow), and operational/technical challenges
Publication Details
Publication Date
2008-03-29
Journal
Publisher
ISSN
Access Type
Author Information
Download PDF
Subscribe to digest
References available in scid.ai7
Application of the SAGD to an Iranian Carbonate Heavy-Oil Reservoir2006
Microscopic Visualization with High Resolution Optical-Fiber Scope at Steam Chamber Interface on Initial Stage of SAGD Process2002
Experimental Modeling of the SAGD Process - Enhancing SAGD Performance with Periodic Stimulation of the Horizontal Producer2001
Review of Phase A Steam-Assisted Gravity-Drainage Test1994
Steam-Assisted Gravity Drainage: Concept, Development, Performance And Future1994
A Steam Assisted Gravity Drainage Model For Tar Sands: Radial Geometry1993
A Steam-Assisted Gravity Drainage Model For Tar Sands: Linear Geometry1992
Cited by5
A Comprehensive Assessment of the Integration of Solvent and Steam for the Extraction of Bitumen Through the Development of Novel Process Models2024
A novel upscaling method for steam-assisted gravity drainage simulations based on a viscosity–temperature model2025
A Multistage Theoretical Model To Characterize the Liquid Level During Steam-Assisted-Gravity-Drainage Process2016
Characterizing the Effects of Lean Zones and Shale Distribution in SAGD Recovery Performance2014
SAGD: R&D for Unlocking Unconventional Heavy-Oil Resources2010