Contesting liberal peace: Russia's emerging model of conflict management

Оспаривая либеральный мир: формирующаяся российская модель управления конфликтами
David Lewis
2022-03-01

Russian peacemakingcoercive mediationconflict managementliberal international orderliberal peacebuilding
Abstract Russia has begun to promote itself internationally as a mediator of conflict and as a ‘peacemaker’. Russian officials cite its extensive experience in managing numerous post-Soviet conflicts and its more recent experience of intervention in civil wars in Syria, Libya, the Central African Republic (CAR) and Nagorno-Karabakh. Russia considers all these activities forms of ‘peacemaking’, but its approach differs radically from the model of liberal peacebuilding that has dominated international practice in the post-Cold War era. It prioritizes authoritarian stability over justice, human rights and democracy and advocates short-term goals of conflict management over long-term goals of conflict resolution. In this article I explain why Russia's norms of peacemaking and conflict management diverged so markedly from liberal peacebuilding norms. I argue that Russia is no longer simply contesting western norms, but developing its own distinct model of conflict management. This model accepts the use of force as an integral element in peacemaking, engages in ‘coercive’ mediation by authoritative actors, and views the West as a geopolitical and normative opponent. This debate over Russia's approach to peace and conflict also offers wider insights into how Russia challenges the norms and practices that underpin the liberal international order.
1
Russia frames the West as both a geopolitical and normative opponent, revealing a broader challenge to the liberal international order.
2
Russia is developing a distinct conflict-management model rather than merely contesting Western norms of liberal peacebuilding.
3
Russia is promoting itself internationally as a mediator and peacemaker based on experience managing post-Soviet conflicts and intervening in civil wars.
4
Russia’s conflict-management approach prioritizes authoritarian stability over justice, human rights, and democracy, and short-term management over long-term conflict resolution.
5
This model treats force as an integral element of peacemaking and relies on coercive mediation by authoritative actors.

Russia’s emerging model of conflict management and peacemaking

The model's divergence from liberal peacebuilding norms, including its prioritization of authoritarian stability, short-term conflict management, use of force, coercive mediation, and opposition to Western norms

Publication Details
Publication Date
2022-03-01
Journal
Publisher
ISSN
Access Type
Author Information
Authors
David Lewis
Explore further
Open the scid.ai AI chat with a ready-made request: it will find papers on a similar topic and help build a literature review.
Find similar papers in the chat →
Make a presentation
100%