Single-blind test of airplane-based hyperspectral methane detection via controlled releases
Однослепое испытание гиперспектрального обнаружения метана с борта самолёта с использованием контролируемых выбросов
2021-01-01
SCID: 54.1/d27t2aj8
Discuss with AI
airplane-based imagingcontrolled methane releaseshyperspectral methane detectionplume quantificationsuper-emitting sources
Figures from the paper
Abstract (AI)
Methane leakage from point sources in the oil and gas industry is a major contributor to global greenhouse gas emissions. The majority of such emissions come from a small fraction of “super-emitting” sources. We evaluate the emission detection and quantification capabilities of Kairos Aerospace’s airplane-based hyperspectral imaging methane emission detection system for methane fluxes of 18–1,025 kg per hour of methane (kgh(CH4)). In blinded controlled releases of methane conducted over 4 days in San Joaquin County, CA, Kairos detected 182 of 200 valid nonzero releases, including all 173 over 15 kgh(CH4) per meter per second (mps) of wind and none of the 12 nonzero releases below 8.3 kgh(CH4)/mps. Nine of the 26 releases in the partial detection range of 5–15 kgh(CH4)/mps were detected. There were no false positives: Kairos did not detect methane during any of the 21 negative controls. Plume quantification accuracy depends on the wind measurement technique, with a parity slope of 1.15 (σ = 0.037, R2 = 0.84, N = 185) using a cup-based wind meter and 1.45 (σ = 0.059, R2 = 0.80, N = 157) using an ultrasonic anemometer. Performance is comparable even with only modeled wind data. For emissions above 15 kgh/mps, quantification error scales as roughly 30%–40% of emission size, even when using wind reanalysis data instead of ground-based measurements. This reflects both uncertainty in wind measurements and in Kairos’ estimates. These findings suggest that at 2 mps winds under favorable environmental conditions in the United States, Kairos could detect and quantify over 50% of total emissions by identifying super-emitting sources.
Key Findings
1
Detection was partial in the 5–15 kg CH₄/m/s range, identifying 9 of 26 releases, while producing no false positives across 21 negative controls.
2
For emissions above 15 kg CH₄/m/s, quantification error was approximately 30%–40% of emission size, and performance remained comparable using modeled or reanalyzed wind data.
3
Kairos Aerospace’s airplane-based hyperspectral system detected 182 of 200 valid nonzero methane releases spanning 18–1,025 kg CH₄ per hour in blinded controlled tests.
4
Quantification accuracy depended on wind measurement method, with parity slopes of 1.15 using cup-based measurements and 1.45 using ultrasonic measurements.
5
The system detected all 173 releases exceeding 15 kg CH₄ per meter per second of wind, but none of the 12 releases below 8.3 kg CH₄/m/s.
6
Under favorable U.S. conditions with 2 m/s winds, the system could detect and quantify more than 50% of total emissions by identifying super-emitting sources.
Research Object
Kairos Aerospace’s airplane-based hyperspectral imaging methane emission detection system applied to controlled methane releases from oil and gas point sources
Research Subject
Methane emission detection sensitivity, false-positive performance, and plume quantification accuracy across release rates and wind-measurement conditions
Publication Details
Publication Date
2021-01-01
Journal
Publisher
ISSN
Open access PDF
Access Type
Author Information
Download PDF
Subscribe to digest