Evidence Relating Health Care Provider Burnout and Quality of Care

Данные о взаимосвязи выгорания медицинских работников и качества медицинской помощи
John P. A. Ioannidis, Tait D. Shanafelt, Jochen Profit, Mickey Trockel, John Bryan Sexton, Kathryn C. Adair, Daniel S. Tawfik, Annette Scheid
2019-10-07

excess significance biashealth care provider burnoutmedical errorsquality of patient caresystematic review
Background: Whether health care provider burnout contributes to lower quality of patient care is unclear. Purpose: To estimate the overall relationship between burnout and quality of care and to evaluate whether published studies provide exaggerated estimates of this relationship. Data Sources: MEDLINE, PsycINFO, Health and Psychosocial Instruments (EBSCO), Mental Measurements Yearbook (EBSCO), EMBASE (Elsevier), and Web of Science (Clarivate Analytics), with no language restrictions, from inception through 28 May 2019. Study Selection: Peer-reviewed publications, in any language, quantifying health care provider burnout in relation to quality of patient care. Data Extraction: 2 reviewers independently selected studies, extracted measures of association of burnout and quality of care, and assessed potential bias by using the Ioannidis (excess significance) and Egger (small-study effect) tests. Data Synthesis: A total of 11 703 citations were identified, from which 123 publications with 142 study populations encompassing 241 553 health care providers were selected. Quality-of-care outcomes were grouped into 5 categories: best practices (n = 14), communication (n = 5), medical errors (n = 32), patient outcomes (n = 17), and quality and safety (n = 74). Relations between burnout and quality of care were highly heterogeneous (I2 = 93.4% to 98.8%). Of 114 unique burnout-quality combinations, 58 indicated burnout related to poor-quality care, 6 indicated burnout related to high-quality care, and 50 showed no significant effect. Excess significance was apparent (73% of studies observed vs. 62% predicted to have statistically significant results; P = 0.011). This indicator of potential bias was most prominent for the least-rigorous quality measures of best practices and quality and safety. Limitation: Studies were primarily observational; neither causality nor directionality could be determined. Conclusion: Burnout in health care professionals frequently is associated with poor-quality care in the published literature. The true effect size may be smaller than reported. Future studies should prespecify outcomes to reduce the risk for exaggerated effect size estimates. Primary Funding Source: Stanford Maternal and Child Health Research Institute.
1
A systematic review identified 123 publications involving 142 study populations and 241,553 health care providers examining burnout and patient-care quality.
2
Among 114 unique burnout–quality combinations, 58 linked burnout to poorer care, 6 linked it to higher-quality care, and 50 found no significant association.
3
Associations between burnout and quality of care were highly heterogeneous across outcome categories, with I² values ranging from 93.4% to 98.8%.
4
Because studies were primarily observational, the review could not establish whether burnout causes changes in care quality or determine the direction of causality.
5
Published studies showed excess significance: 73% reported statistically significant findings versus 62% expected, with potential bias strongest for less-rigorous quality measures.

health care provider burnout and quality of patient care

the overall association between burnout and quality of care, including its heterogeneity and potential publication-related biases

Publication Details
Publication Date
2019-10-07
Journal
Publisher
ISSN
Cited by
555
Access Type
Author Information
Authors
John P. A. Ioannidis
Tait D. Shanafelt
Jochen Profit
Mickey Trockel
John Bryan Sexton
Kathryn C. Adair
Daniel S. Tawfik
Annette Scheid
Explore further
Open the scid.ai AI chat with a ready-made request: it will find papers on a similar topic and help build a literature review.
Find similar papers in the chat →
Make a presentation
100%