The Discipline of Rankings: Tight Coupling and Organizational Change
Дисциплина рейтингов: тесная связанность и организационные изменения
2009-02-01
SCID: 54.1/ebmxeh5d
Discuss with AI
Foucault’s disciplineinstitutional pressuresorganizational decouplingorganizational rankingssurveillance and normalization
Figures from the paper
Abstract (AI)
This article demonstrates the value of Foucault's conception of discipline for understanding organizational responses to rankings. Using a case study of law schools, we explain why rankings have permeated law schools so extensively and why these organizations have been unable to buffer these institutional pressures. Foucault's depiction of two important processes, surveillance and normalization, show how rankings change perceptions of legal education through both coercive and seductive means. This approach advances organizational theory by highlighting conditions that affect the prevalence and effectiveness of buffering. Decoupling is not determined solely by the external enforcement of institutional pressures or the capacity of organizational actors to buffer or hide some activities. Members' tendency to internalize these pressures, to become self-disciplining, is also salient. Internalization is fostered by the anxiety that rankings produce, by their allure for the administrators who try to manipulate them, and by the resistance they provoke. Rankings are just one example of the public measures of performance that are becoming increasingly influential in many institutional environments, and understanding how organizations respond to these measures is a crucial task for scholars.
Key Findings
1
Foucault’s concepts of surveillance and normalization explain how rankings reshape perceptions of legal education through coercive and seductive mechanisms.
2
Law school rankings have extensively permeated organizations because members internalize ranking pressures rather than simply buffering or decoupling from them.
3
Organizational responses to institutional pressures depend not only on external enforcement and buffering capacity, but also on self-disciplining internalization.
4
Ranking-induced anxiety, administrators’ desire to manipulate rankings, and resistance to rankings foster their internalization within law schools.
5
The analysis suggests that public performance measures can substantially influence organizations across institutional environments, making their effects important for organizational theory.
Research Object
Law schools as organizations subjected to external rankings
Research Subject
organizational responses to rankings, including surveillance, normalization, pressure internalization, and decoupling or buffering of institutional pressures
Publication Details
Publication Date
2009-02-01
Journal
Publisher
ISSN
Open access PDF
Access Type
Author Information
Download PDF
Subscribe to digest