Can Six Minutes of Culturally Competent Evolution Education Reduce Students' Level of Perceived Conflict Between Evolution and Religion?
Могут ли шесть минут культурно компетентного обучения эволюции снизить воспринимаемый студентами уровень конфликта между эволюцией и религией?
2018-01-30
SCID: 54.1/grspe622
Discuss with AI
cultural competenceevolution educationqualitative analysisreligion-evolution conflictstudent acceptance of evolution
Figures from the paper
Abstract (AI)
Evolution is foundational to biology but is controversial for many undergraduate students. Although evolution and religion are potentially compatible, students' perceived conflict between their religious beliefs and evolution can negatively affect their acceptance of evolution. In a previous study, we found that illustrating the potential compatibility of religion and evolution decreased the number of students who perceived a conflict between religion and evolution by 53 percent. However, in the previous study, the instruction on the potential compatibility of religion and evolution took a significant amount of instructional time, which could be a barrier for implementation. In this current study, we condensed the instruction illustrating the potential compatibility of religion and evolution to six minutes. By conducting qualitative analyses on data gathered from ten students who perceived a conflict before the evolution module, we found that eight of these students reduced their level of perceived conflict after the evolution module. We identified eight distinct aspects of the evolution instruction that students stated reduced their perceived conflict, including that the instructor did not force student acceptance of evolution, the instructor was respectful of students with multiple viewpoints on evolution, and students experienced a greater exposure to evolution content.
Key Findings
1
A six-minute lesson illustrating compatibility between religion and evolution reduced perceived conflict for 8 of 10 initially conflicted students.
2
Students identified eight aspects that reduced perceived conflict, including non-coercive teaching, instructor respect for multiple viewpoints, and greater exposure to evolution content.
3
The condensed instruction preserved the conflict-reducing effect while requiring substantially less instructional time than the prior intervention.
4
The findings suggest culturally competent evolution instruction can address religious-evolution conflict without forcing students to accept evolution.
Research Object
Undergraduate students who perceive a conflict between evolution and religion
Research Subject
Reduction and contributing aspects of students’ perceived conflict between evolution and religion following six minutes of culturally competent evolution instruction
Publication Details
Publication Date
2018-01-30
Journal
Publisher
ISSN
Access Type
Author Information
Download PDF
Subscribe to digest